12 Best All Day Butt Plugs [2021 Review]: Most Comfortable & Wearable

To find the best all day butt plug, you need to keep quite a bit of things in mind to have the most comfortable long term wear enjoyable. Read on:

All Day Butt Plugs

Butt plugs are one of the most discreet ways to get some pleasure while you’re doing your regular activities. 

Whether it’s going to work, shopping, or just doing chores around the house, doing it while wearing a butt plug is a great way to keep your motor running until you have time to let off the tension. 

But for ALL-DAY use, you need the right tools for the job. 

So today, we’re looking at the 12 best butt plugs for all-day wear. (If you’re looking for all purpose butt plug guide we have that too).

You can leave these babies in for hours. 

If you crave that so much you can’t even wait till the end of this list, here’s the Top 3.

SexualAlpha Top Pick

My top pick is the B-Vibe Snug Plug 1. This treasure will fit your body comfortably thanks to its unique design and long, flexible neck. But it has edges and weight for added stimulation all day! 

Most Comfortable All-Day Butt Plug

The SquarePeg Blunt Plug might sound a bit harsh, but it’s like giving your butt a memory foam pillow. It’s incredibly squishy but retains its shape once inside, so you get that full feeling without any hard edges or poking at all. Stretching with minimal effort? Yes please! 

Best For Beginners

The Blush Luxe Wearable is the best for beginners thanks to its small rounded egg shape and wide anchor base. It holds lube nicely for easy removal. And the long neck relative to the bulb means it’s not going anywhere all day. Plus, it’s affordable! 


Top 3 All Day Anal Plugs In 2021

Most Comfortable All-Day Butt Plug

SquarePegToys Blunt Plug

SquarePeg Blunt Plug

SexualAlpha Top Pick

B-Vibe Snug Plug 1

Best For Beginners

Blush Luxe Wearable

Insertable Length:
3.5” – 5.6” 
3.4”
2.75” – 3”
Diameter:
1.59” – 1.9”
0.8”
1” – 1.5”
Material:
Silicone
Silicone
Silicone
Color:
Bronze
Black, Pink
Black, Purple

Top All Day Anal Plugs In 2021

SexualAlpha Top Pick

1. B-Vibe Snug Plug 1 

Insertable Length:
3.4”
Diameter:
0.8”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Blue
  • Comfortable yet very stimulating
  • Weighted for extra pressure despite small size
  • Smooth-grip t-base is easy to remove
  • Holds odor a little more than other plugs
  • Not the softest

You might think that a rounded, softer-looking butt plug would be the best choice for extended wear. 

But here comes the Snug Plug to prove you wrong. 

Its innovative torpedo shape looks pointy and hard, but that’s a good thing. 

Why? 

The pointed tip makes it super easy to insert, and the contours fit your internal canal while adding some extra stimulation. 

What’s more, it has a long, thin neck that the sphincter can relax around, keeping things comfy around the ring so the rest of your butt can enjoy being filled. 

The t-base is wide and thin, so it sits perfectly between your butt cheeks and doesn’t stick out under your clothes, keeping things nice and stealthy. 

It’s heavier than you might expect for its tiny size, thanks to the added weight inside. The extra heft makes internal movement feel more intense and pleasurable. 

The silicone material isn’t ultra-soft like some of the other plugs on this list, but that makes it more stimulating while still being… snug. Hence the name, I guess. 

And if you like the Snug Plug 1 but wish it was a little bigger, good news! There’s a whole range of Snug Plugs from 1 to 6. 

The largest is 2.2 inches in diameter and weighs about a pound, so even the most demanding of butts should be satisfied. 


Most Comfortable All-Day Butt Plug

2. SquarePeg Blunt Plug

Insertable Length:
3.5” – 5.6”
Diameter:
1.59” – 3.5”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Bronze, Graphite Gray
  • Squishy silicone molds to your shape
  • Designed for stretching as well as all-day wear
  • 11 sizes to choose from
  • Wider neck might not be comfy for beginners at first
  • Base sticks out under tight clothing

If you want the anal equivalent of reclining on a chaise-lounge while servants feed you peeled grapes and chocolates all day, then the Blunt Plug was made for you. 

It’s not as stimulating as the B-Vibe above, but it’s so soft and full-feeling it’s like your favorite pillow. If you put your favorite pillow in your butt, I guess. 

And if you’re planning on wearing tight clothes, you might want to reconsider because the Blunt Plug’s base will stick out noticeably. 

So how does it work? It’s malleable and compresses as you insert it but then expands back to its original shape once it gets past the sphincter for that happy, filled feeling. 

It comes in 11 sizes, ranging from “small and adorable” to “wow you must have trained like an Olympian to even consider that!” 

The smaller 6 sizes are best suited for long-term wear, while the big ones are for serious stretch training that you should do in private. 

But they all have thick necks that make them perfect for anal training in style and comfort. 


Best For Beginners

3. Blush Luxe Wearable

Insertable Length:
2.75” – 3”
Diameter:
1” – 1.5”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Black, Purple
  • Round bulb is very filling
  • Long, thin neck is gentle on the sphincter
  • Small size is easy for newbies
  • Internal ball-bearing doesn’t stimulate as much as promised 
  • Bendy neck is slightly awkward to insert

No experience with all-day butt plugs? No sweat, the Blush Luxe Wearable is here for you. 

It comes in two sizes, small and medium, which share the same simple but effective design. 

It has a long, bendy neck that keeps it in place and is great for the sphincter to relax around comfortably

The long neck does mean it’s a bit more of a hassle to insert. Just hold the bottom of the bulb and push gently, letting your body do the work. It’s not that hard. 

The Blush Luxe Wearable also has a weighted ball-bearing inside that’s supposed to deliver “motion-activated vibrations” from the ball moving around inside. 

It feels good during sex or if you’re on the treadmill, but if you’re just walking around you can’t really notice much. 

Still, it’s small, silky-smooth, and very well designed, so it’s perfect for all-day wear even if it’s your first time. 


Softest All Day Butt Plug

4. Oxballs Ergo

Insertable Length:
2.75” – 5.75”
Diameter:
1.3” – 2.7”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Swirly black and gray mix, black
  • Warm, rubbery silicone feels amazing
  • Flat base means you can sit on it to insert
  • Unique and pretty design
  • Squishy silicone attracts dust and dirt

Oxballs Ergo looks wide and fat, but it’s made of soft and pliable silicone that compresses to fit you. 

The curled bean-shaped bulb aligns nicely with your internal canal so it’s supremely ergonomic in design. 

It’s easy to insert – just put it on a flat surface and lower yourself down onto it. 

It has a wide, flat base that’s safe to wear all day, but also squishes between your butt cheeks to stay comfortable and discreet

One thing that many butt plugs struggle with is sitting positions, like if you’re at your computer. 

Hard pointy ends and edges can cause discomfort if you don’t move around a lot.

But the Ergo is so gentle that you won’t get any poking or prodding where you don’t want it. 

Ergo, it’s the best plug for taking to the office if you feel like making work a little NSFW…


Best Vibrating All Day Butt Plug

5. Doc Johnson A-Play

Insertable Length:
4.25”
Diameter:
1.5”
Material:
Silicone, ABS Plastic
Color:
Black, Teal
Battery Life:
1 hour
  • 10 vibrating functions
  • Quiet, rumbly vibes
  • Splashproof, not waterproof – no fun in the bath

The A-play is a standard shaped butt plug that’s smooth and has a good balance between soft and firm, so it’s good to wear for several hours. 

But the fun part is that it vibrates. 

The vibrations are rumbly, but so quiet

Once it’s inside there’s no way anyone outside is gonna hear the vibration even on higher settings. Well, maybe if you’re in a library. 

The remote control has just one button that cycles through the vibe functions. It has a range of about 15 feet – awesome for a romantic dinner date with a side of kinky fun. 

The rechargeable battery lasts for about an hour on a full charge, so don’t expect it to vibrate all day. Save the charge for more special moments. 

Sure there are stronger butt plugs out there, but few combine power, quietness, and comfort in one plug like the A-play does. 

You can use the discount code ALPHA15 for 15% off purchases over $49.


Best Metal All Day Butt Plug

6. NJoy Pure Plug

Insertable Length:
3”
Diameter:
1”
Material:
Stainless Steel
Color:
Silver
  • Smooth, easy to insert and remove
  • Hard metal is very stimulating
  • Small and ergonomically shaped
  • Not good for sitting down 

Most metal plugs aren’t suited for long-term use. 

They’re hard, inflexible, and impossible to ignore – sexy, but impractical if you’re walking around. 

The NJoy Pure Plug is the best solution for a metal plug.

It’s ergonomically shaped to fit the natural curve of your anal passage, so it’s easier to leave in. 

And it has a thin neck for your hole to relax around with no problems.

The only downside is the base. It’s a ring shape which is great for insertion and removal but makes it impossible to sit down comfortably for longer than a few minutes. 

Still, if you want that addictive feeling of hard metal inside you all day, this is your best bet.


Cheap All Day Butt Plug

7. Mood Naughty Small Plug

Insertable Length:
3”
Diameter:
1”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Black, Pink
  • Easy to insert 
  • Long neck 
  • Tip is a bit firm and pointy
  • T-base is bigger than necessary

20 bucks doesn’t get you a lot these days, but it will get you all-day anal fun. 

The Mood Naughty is a simple plug with a tapered body and a long neck for convenient extended wear.

The wide t-base keeps things safe. Maybe a bit too safe? The width means the edges might poke the balls (if you have those). 

But at this price, who am I to complain? 


Best Colorful All-Day Plug

8. Avant Pride P6 Beyond

Insertable Length:
3.75”
Diameter:
1.25”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Tri-color: purple/white/green
  • Gentle taper is good for beginners
  • Pretty colors
  • Relatively small bulb-neck ratio, might slip out

Look how pretty! Avant always makes the cutest things to go in the butthole. 

The size difference between the neck and the bulb isn’t the biggest, so more seasoned anal adventurers might find it slips out too easily if you’re doing activities. 

But if you’re a beginner who wants a cheap long-term plug that’s also a fashion statement, the P6 was made for you. 


Stimulating Beginner Plug

9. Tantus Perfect Plug

Insertable Length:
3.5”
Diameter:
0.75”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Black, Purple
  • Super thin, anyone can use it
  • Extra bulb for extra feeling
  • Length makes it a bit pointy

If you can get your pinkie finger in your butt, you can get the Perfect Plug in there.

It’s only ¾ of an inch at its widest point, so it’ll even work for anal virgins

The Perfect Plug has a thin neck and equally thin t-base that snuggles between the cheeks like it was MADE to be there. 

And it has another bulb underneath the main one that makes thrusting with it more fun when playing alone or with a partner. 

It’s a bit too long for extended use if you’re sitting down, but if you’re moving around with it this really might be the perfect plug.

You can use the discount code SEXUALALPHA20 for 20% off at checkout.


Best All-Day Plug For Stretching

10. Tantus Neo

Insertable Length:
4”
Diameter:
1.4”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Black, Purple
  • Thicker neck for casual stretching
  • Seems to stay lubed up for longer
  • Thicker neck means your sphincter can’t rest

Wanna stretch while you’re on the go? 

Neo is your plug! 

Somehow it seems to stay lubed up for longer than some of the other toys, which is awesome for wearing all day or even overnight. 

It’s made of the same satin-finish silicone as the Tantus Perfect Plug, but it has a fuller bulb and thicker neck for that filling sensation. 

The thick neck stretches your sphincter so it’s good for anal training. 

Probably not good for newbies since the neck doesn’t allow the butt hole to rest, but it’s a good step up for discreet outdoor stretching. 


Cheap Butt Plug For Moving Around

11. Luxe Anal Trainer Set

Insertable Length:
2.5” – 4”
Diameter:
0.75” – 1.25”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Black, Pink
  • Tapered base moves while staying secure
  • Thin tip is easy to insert
  • Tip is a bit pointy
  • Not as filling as some of the others

You want a plug that’s going to stay securely inside you, of course. 

But you also want to feel a little movement to keep yourself stimulated. 

This Luxe set offers both. The neck widens out towards the base instead of cutting off at a right angle. 

Having a butt plug that moves a bit while you go about your business keeps things interesting all day.

Incredibly hot once you get used to the feeling.

The widening neck means as you move around it will slide a bit and keep you on your toes. 

It has that long, flexible neck that ensure it will stay in place, so you still don’t have to worry about it traveling too far. 

You can use the discount code SEXUALALPHA for 10% off at checkout.


Comfortable Larger All-Day Butt Plug

12. Pipedream Anal Fantasy

Insertable Length:
4.25”
Diameter:
2”
Material:
Silicone
Color:
Black
  • Bulb feels oddly perfect
  • Tapered fit
  • Comfortable base
  • Only comes in black
  • Loses lube quickly

The Pipedream Anal Fantasy looks like just another ordinary butt plug. 

And yet there’s something about the shape of the bulb that just hits perfectly. 

Something about the curve, or the taper, or the neck to bulb ratio, I really don’t know. I want to hire a mathematician to figure out if it follows the golden ratio or something. 

Anyways, it’s pretty fat, has a nice base, and is gonna feel amazing if you wear it for five minutes or five hours

Just keep it lubed up regularly as the silicone seems to dry up the lube a bit faster than some other plugs.


The All-Day Butt Plug Buying Guide

As we mentioned earlier, your best butt plug choice should tick 3 main boxes:

  • A thin neck;
  • A wide flat base;
  • And be made of SOFT n’ BENDY silicone. 

Let’s look at why, plus a few more considerations for your butt plug shopping trip.

Neck And Base

The thin neck is essential because it causes less friction to the delicate skin inside your anus.

So, it’s safer but it’s also more comfortable. 

Letting your butthole relax around a skinny neck means you can wear your butt plug for longer. 

What about that base?

Well, a flat, wide base has a few benefits: 

  • It’s easier to sit down;
  • It’s more discreet under your clothes;
  • And ensures no ‘traveling’ of the butt plug and no awkward trips to the Emergency Room!

When it comes to the diameter of the plug – think of the width of the toy you can already handle and move in 0.25” increments from there. That way you can stretch safely. 

Materials

Silicone is always our material of choice when it comes to sex toys, but in this case, there is one extra consideration. Go for SOFT and FLEXIBLE silicone. 

Why?

Because some silicone toys are firmer than others. But for long-term ass wear, you need it to be flexible enough to move with your body throughout the day.

Sure, you can find butt plugs in metal, ceramic, and glass (even the inflatable butt plugs are popular nowadays). They may tick the first two boxes of the thin neck and the flat, wide base…but these materials are NOT FLEXIBLE. 

They do not move with your body and they are NOT safe nor comfortable for all-day wear.

What about plastic or PVC butt plugs? 

Nope. Avoid.

These are highly porous materials and can’t be sanitized. You’re sticking this up your butt remember. So keep it clean!

Lube

YOU NEED A LOT. 

While silicone lube is ideal for anal play, as it’s thick and lasts longer, it might not be the best option for your all-day butt plug-wearing.

Silicone lube can break down the material and ruin your butt plug. 

Instead, go for oil-based or water-based lubricant and reapply throughout the day.

Oil-based lubes are thicker and won’t dry up as quickly, but they can be a little messy. Ever spill cooking oil on your shirt? Nightmare to wash out. The same happens with oil-based lubes. 

Water-based lubes are compatible with any type of toy material AND they won’t stain your clothes. I like Sliquid Silk as it is a water and silicone blend that is safe to use, yet lasts for a long time.


All-Day Wear Butt Plugs Safety Checklist

Get the most pleasure from extended butt plug wear in the safest way possible, by following these simple rules: 

Work up to all-day wear: Start with shorter times, wearing it around the house. Test sitting and moving at home before you go on any adventures. Then, build it up to longer times.

Start with small plugs: Your butt hole isn’t used to carrying objects around! Start with a small butt plug and gradually increase the size.

Lube: Always. And copious amounts of the stuff! Keep things slick. Friction can mean tears. Tears mean pain!

Avoid porous materials: The butt is a whole world of bacteria and you don’t want that seeping into your butt plug.

Always clean butt plugs thoroughly: Silicone butt plugs are easy to clean. Some can be popped into the dishwasher, or sanitized in boiling water.

Avoid wearing if suffering from tummy trouble: We’re talking diarrhea here. It might be obvious, but worth stating just in case! 

Take it out to use the loo: Obvious when it comes to pooping! But you should also remove it before urinating. Trust me, no-one wants to fish a butt plug out of the toilet. 

How Long Can You Wear A Butt Plug?

There is no definitive answer to how long you can wear a butt plug. Some people will say that you shouldn’t wear them for longer than 2-3 hours at a time.

While other “lifestyle butt pluggers” claim to wear their anal plugs for up to 20 hours a day. 

They sleep with it in and only take it out for a couple of hours in the morning and at night…to answer nature’s call! 

With anything anal, I say it’s always best to err on the side of caution…

Is It Safe To Wear Butt Plugs All Day?

You might have heard a load of horror stories about anal bleeding or anal incontinence caused by all-day anal butt plugs.

But take these stories with a pinch of salt. Most have been widely exaggerated for shock value. 

That said, any sort of butt play comes with a risk. All-day anal CAN be safe…as long as you do it sensibly. Refer to the safety checklist above. 

And remember…

Everybody is different. You might have dreams of wearing a butt plug all day but always listen to your body. Your fantasy might be 9 hours, but your limit might be 3. 

Don’t push it. The moment you begin to feel any soreness, discomfort, or your muscles getting tired, take a break. 

Can You Wear Your Butt Plug While Sleeping?

You can wear a butt plug while sleeping and many advanced long-term users do. Just be sure that it’s a plug you’re well used to and have already practiced wearing for long periods first.

Two things to be aware of though…

Firstly, pain receptors in your body pretty much shut down while you sleep. So, you could damage yourself without noticing. 

And secondly, extended butt plug wearing requires a lot of lube. While you’re asleep, you’re not lubing up. So removal is going to be tricky. And painful.

So it’s your choice, but personally, I’m WAY too grumpy in the morning to deal with that hassle. 

If it’s your dream, go for it. If not, just put it in in the morning and take it out at night. Much easier.


Conclusion

Wearing a buttplug keeps you on edge all day so when you finally get home and down to something sexy, you’ve got all that built-up energy from a day of teasing yourself. 

Sounds good, doesn’t it? 

So grab a plug and some lube and get going! 

Anastasia

Anastasia

Anastasia is a sex toy reviewer and a part of the SexualAlpha's Core Team.

Got Questions? Ping me on Twitter.