There is no best butt plug – there can only be the right one for YOUR specific needs. Below we review all the right choices for different cases. Read on:
It’s SHOCKINGLY easy to find a bad buttplug that can turn you off of the idea of anal play completely.
But finding a good buttplug?
So you’ll be pleased to know that I’ve waded through all of the crap (figuratively) to find you the 25 best butt plugs money can buy.
So while there is no One Buttplug to Rule Them All, on this list you should find the buttplug that’s the lord to your ring (sorry).
And for most of you, there’s a good chance it’ll be one of my TOP THREE.
Best Vibrating Plug
The best vibrations come in the Lovense Hush, which is my overall favorite butt plug. It has tons of connectivity features, is well-designed for easy insertion and removal, and the power is CRAZY.
Best Glass Design
For something besides silicone, the Pipedreams Icicle No 48 is a gorgeous glass plug that’s easy to use, durable and safe, works with all kinds of lube, and did I mention how pretty it is?
Top 3 Glass, Vibrating Butt & Anal Plugs in 2023
Pipedreams Icicle No 48
Mood Naughty Trainer Kit
Top Rated Butt & Anal Plugs
The Lovense Hush has it all. Starting with the motor, which is incredibly powerful. I don’t know about any butt plugs that even compare.
And it’s pretty quiet on the lower settings, too. If you stick to the first few levels you could even use it in public and no-one would be any the wiser.
On higher settings, things do get a bit noisy, like a low speaking level. It is definitely noticeable in quiet spaces, so be careful taking it outside and cranking it up to the max!
The Hush also has awesome connectivity functions.
Using the Lovense app you can control the vibrations over the internet (great for long-distance couples).
You can use new user-created patterns from the app for infinite patterns, or create your own. You can set it to sound-activated, so when it “hears” a sound it will buzz.
It even syncs to music! That’s a whole new way to appreciate your favorite songs. “Yeah the new single sounds good, but it doesn’t feel that good in my butt. 7/10.”
The design touches are impressive too. That spiral on the neck? It helps to trap some lube there so you can take it out more easily — and it works!
The base is comfortable and practical, and the tip is just the right balance of rounded and pointy to make entry smooth and painless.
Downsides? Well the silicone is a dust magnet and there’s no storage pouch, so you’ll have to wrap it up for storage to keep dust off of it.
At 1.5 inches wide it’s also a bit big for anyone new to anal play, but for everyone else, it’s a top choice.
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, Lovense Hush is on sale for $99 (from $119).
If you want to know more details about the Lovense Hush, we have an in-depth review here.
Check out other great toys in our best vibrating butt plug guide.
The borosilicate glass it’s made of is strong enough to survive a drop and is temperature resistant, so you can heat it up or cool it down safely.
The rounded teardrop shape makes it easy to insert with any kind of lube (yes, even silicone lube is on the table!).
It has a gradual taper that leads down to a pretty wide neck.
A wide neck can be good or bad.
It’s good because it stretches the sphincter so it’s good for preparing for anal sex or larger toys.
On the other hand, keeping the sphincter stretched is uncomfortable after a short while, so you can’t wear the Icicles for a long time.
If you’ve been looking for a fake jewel plug then try this instead — it’s safer and in my opinion better looking!
The N-Joy Pure Small is.
140 grams of pure stainless steel with a nice curve that hits your p-spot if you have one and stimulates you anyway if you don’t.
It comes in a gorgeous box that’s practically a keepsake all by itself, so it would make a great gift for a special someone in your life.
Everything about the N-joy screams luxury, from the mirror polish, that you can see your face in, to the beautiful oval ring base that makes removing it a breeze.
The base means it will stick out under clothes, so it’s not the best choice for wearing in public, but well nothing is perfect is it?
Oh yeah, the metal is cold at first (obviously) but you can heat it up in warm water or put it in the fridge if you feel like playing with the temperature.
We’ve made an article on the best metal butt plugs for other great options that you might want to check.
If you’re looking for an app-controlled vibrating butt plug, this is another great option.
One of the things I really love about the Lumen is the FeelConnect option. This lets you sync the plug with any other KIIROO toy so you and your partner can experience the same vibration settings and patterns at the same time.
This is a fun option for long-distance couples or if you simply want to introduce something new into the bedroom. You could even sync it with a vibrator and experience synchronized double penetration!
Just a finger wide but there’s a hell of a lot you can do with a finger.
The torpedo shape makes a way more intense feeling inside than you might expect, yet it never feels like it’s stretching that much.
The weights inside make you feel more full and do some nice work on your pleasure points as you walk.
It has a long, thin neck that makes it easy to keep in comfortably for extended time (Check here for more all day-butt plugs).
You can go about your whole day with it in and probably even sleep wearing it if that’s your thing.
The T-base rests comfortably between your cheeks without digging in, so you could even go for a run and no-one would ever notice you secretly getting off.
Well, unless you moan as you run. That’s a giveaway.
And if you like the Snug Plug 1, you can graduate to the Snug Plug 2, which is bigger. Actually, they have a range that goes all the way from the adorable 1 to the intimidating Snug Plug 6, which is 2.2 inches wide and weighs 500g.
The b-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 has a bunch of beads in the neck of the plug which rotate to help recreate the sensation of analingus, AKA rimming AKA having your butt licked.
Does it manage to live up to this impressive claim?
Well, yes and no.
No, it doesn’t feel like actual rimming from a human person…
But DAMN it feels great!
The combination of the vibrating tip to jangle your insides while the rotating beads wreak havoc on your sphincter is an insanely intense experience.
The Rimming Plug 2 also comes with a remote control so a partner can control the action from a distance.
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, b-Vibe Rimming Plug 2 is on sale for $112.50 (from $150).
The Lovehoney Inflatable Plug is amazing value at just $25, so it’s not even expensive to try it out.
It has a soft plastic outer shell over a solid core, so it’s easy to insert. Once it’s inside you can pump it up by squeezing the pump and make it vibrate using the dial-controlled remote.
A common problem with inflatable plugs is that they tend to move around while they’re being inflated. But not this one. It stays in place and vibrates like crazy!
If you can (or you’re playing with a partner), deflate the plug while orgasming to make it more intense. It lasts longer and feels stronger.
I wish the remote was a little bit longer to make controlling it more convenient, but at this price, I can hardly complain.
NOTE: This plug does contain latex, so if you’re allergic then you’ll have to give this one a miss. And if you’re not sure whether you’re allergic to latex, you should test it with a latex glove before putting anything in your butt.
Consider checking out our best inflatable butt plug guide for more options.
Aneros Helix Trident is a thin, light prostate massager made of hard yet flexible plastic and contours designed to tickle the p-spot like there’s no tomorrow.
The outer arms keep it secure and safe while also stimulating the perineum (taint) and so-called “kundalini spot,” which is somewhere around the base of the spine.
It’s a good idea to try many different positions to see which one works best for you. I find lying on my side or back to be the best but every guy and every prostate is different.
Once you find the right position it should be possible to have hands-free orgasms just by relaxing and taking some deep breaths, then enjoying the sensations as they wash over you.
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, Aneros Helix Trident is on sale for $38.49 (from $55).
The Dominix Fox Tail is a beautiful faux fur fox tail attached to a lovely and heavy stainless steel plug.
The plug itself is 1.6 inches wide and as firm as you would expect from a dense metal, so if you’re a novice of the butt you’ll have to train up to that size with something softer.
The tail is nice and fluffy, but a bit shorter than you might expect from the picture. Plus, it doesn’t really swish around since the core is quite solid.
You could get another tail to attach to the plug since the tail attachment IS removable. That is a nice touch in case you just want the plug for an evening without fur getting in the way.
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, Dominix Fox Tail is on sale for $22.49 (from $50).
Vixen Creation’s Tristan is one of the best stretching plugs out there.
They’re made of platinum silicone which is top quality, easy to clean, and very firm.
That firmness is actually a good thing for stretching toys because it makes it easier to insert — you don’t need to push so hard to get it inside.
And once it’s fully inserted the thick neck keeps the sphincter open so you can relax and enjoy the full, stretched-out feeling.
The bulb isn’t much wider than the neck so it’s easy to take out and get into anal sex.
I wouldn’t recommend these if you’re looking for something to wear for a long time. The hard material gets uncomfortable pretty quickly, even after 10-15 minutes.
BUT for preparing your butt for other activities, they’re outstanding.
If you want a jeweled butt plug, you can’t go wrong with the Haka Pretty Plug.
Each teardrop-shaped plug is a work of art that wouldn’t look out of place in a display case.
They’re all made of heavy and super-durable stainless steel. You can feel the weight and quality difference between these and cheap crappy “metal god-knows-what alloy” plugs.
And they’re as durable and long-lasting as you would expect from stainless steel.
Note on the size: 1.6” in girth might not sound like all that much, but keep in mind that steel doesn’t flex as silicone does, so it will feel bigger and harder to work with.
That means the large option is really for intermediate to advanced anal players, despite outward appearances. The small is still good for beginners.
For other great options, see our best jewel butt plug guide.
When it comes to vibrating butt plugs, you generally get what you pay for.
The We-Vibe Ditto is no exception. At $130 it qualifies as a luxury toy, and it 100% delivers on that promise.
It’s quite similar to the Lovense Hush (my #1 pick) but is easier to insert and more comfortable for anyone to wear long-term.
It has deep, rumbly vibrations which are the best kind for butt stuff.
It’s got a sweet forward-facing design to help the vibrations penetrate even deeper into your body and stimulate the p-spot (if you have one). The Ditto is fully waterproof too so it’s easy to clean and will work in the shower.
The remote isn’t fully waterproof though, so don’t bring that with you!
The remote control is nice and discreet if you’re into stealthy public play, or there’s the We-Connect app, which can connect the toy to any smartphone for long-distance remote control.
NOTE: Whenever I used the We-Connect app it worked great, but some users say it was buggy or unresponsive for them. Your mileage may vary.
Looking for hands-free, remote-controlled butt plug alternatives? Check out other great options here.
Interested in learning more? Read our in-depth review here.
1.5 inches might not sound like a lot, but when it’s going in your butt every tenth of an inch makes a noticeable difference.
So the Tantus Ryder isn’t necessarily a good plug for novices.
It has a broad, rounded tip which means it’s harder to insert if you’re not used to it, and it quickly widens even further to increase the stretching sensation.
But then it reaches a certain threshold and slides in effortlessly like magic, leaving you with a satisfying feeling of fullness.
Once it’s in, it’s really comfortable. The Ryder can easily be an all-day plug if that’s what you’re looking for.
Pro Tip: Type in SEXUALALPHA20 upon checkout on Tantus for a 20% off discount.
The Sensi is actually a pussy plug, meaning it goes in… well take a guess!
It has a small base that means unfortunately it’s not suitable as a butt plug since it could get sucked up in there.
Made of soft squishy silicone, this beautiful plug is great for pelvic floor exercises or to give you something to clench on while masturbating.
(You or your partner could hold on to it and use it for anal stimulation, as long as you keep a tight hold on it and don’t try to leave it in.)
Each plug is handmade from platinum silicone that looks great and is gorgeous to the touch.
You may also want to consider checking out our best pussy plug guide for more options.
Another stylish vibrating option, the Desire Luxury is everything you want in a butt plug.
Unlike plugs that rely on textured silicone to provide sensation, this toy is all about good vibes, baby. With 8 speed settings and 12 patterns to choose from, this remote-controlled toy delivers just that.
The only thing to watch out for is the size. At 4 inches in length, this might be uncomfortably large if you’re not used to bigger plugs.
A butt plug with a light-up control panel isn’t something you see every day. It can be easy to lose track of which vibration setting you’re on, especially if you’re not the one wearing the toy!
The Mantric does away with the confusion by incorporating a color-coded light-up panel into its design. This is great for knowing exactly what your partner’s experiencing.
The only downside is the one-cycle motor. This means you can only move up in your vibration settings, not down.
Cheap Butt Plugs
The Pipedream Mini is basically the blueprint of what a standard newbie buttplug should look like.
Tapered tip for easy entry? Check.
Nice wide base? Check.
Narrow neck to keep it in place? Yep.
Hygienic, non-porous silicone? You bet.
It doesn’t do anything spectacular or fancy, it’s just a nice cheap buttplug that does everything you need it to.
Do you want to explore your back passage (or your partner’s) but you only have $11-$13?
No problem! Introducing the Calexotics Booty Rocker.
Slow increases and decreases in width are always a good option for anyone who is new to anal play.
So with a bulbous tip that slims down before thickening back up, you get a lovely rippling sensation as you insert it and take it out.
And while the bulbous end might make it a little harder to penetrate with than a pointy end, it’s worth the effort.
Downsides? The base is a bit too big to be used for DP as it can chafe the guy’s shaft, which is a common issue for a lot of buttplugs.
Doc Johnson is a legend in pleasure products, and the Mood Naughty range is just more evidence that they know what they’re doing.
They’ve got something for everyone, from terrifyingly huge stretching toys all the way down to this: the Mood Naughty Small.
At just 0.75 inches wide at its widest point and very tapered, it’s a good place to start for anyone looking to experiment with anal play.
On top of that, it’s hypoallergenic, easy to clean, and comfortable enough to wear around town if that’s your thing.
For just around $20 this plug is a good deal…
…But you can also get it as part of a kit if your budget can stretch a little wider (see no.19 on this list.) As part of the three together it’s even cheaper!
Best Beginner Butt & Anal Plugs
Getting three plugs instead of one is a brilliant way to train yourself to take bigger sizes for more pleasure.
The smallest of these Doc Johnson models is about the size of a finger, which is about as non-threatening as a plug can be. The biggest is 1.25 inches wide, so two fingers.
They all have long, very tapered heads which makes inserting a breeze even if you’re brand new to the practice.
The set comes in black, pink, or pride colors (clear with rainbow sprinkles), which is nice to have the choice of. Not every buttplug needs to be black. 😉
In fact, they’re so good for anal training that you’ll quickly find yourself wanting something girthier to satisfy your newfound lusts.
As anal trainer kits go, the Calexotics is very similar to the Doc Johnson kit above.
They’re both made of quality silicone that feels matte smooth to the touch.
They each come with three plugs: small, medium, and large.
They’re both very reasonably priced.
The major difference is in shape. The Calexotics are fatter with a smoother gradient, which will make you feel more full and satisfied, but at the cost of being slightly harder to insert.
Not difficult, though — thanks to the tapered shape even a novice shouldn’t have any trouble getting the smallest plug to fit.
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, Calexotics Anal Kit is on sale for $27.99 (from $35).
Tantus Perfect Plug is only ¾ of an inch wide at most, which is about the same as my index finger.
It has a beautiful velvety finish that doesn’t cling like many other silicone toys, so it’s really easy to insert.
It has a nice long neck, wide base AND it’s budget-friendly, too!
The only issue I had with it is the base. It’s thin and fits snugly between the cheeks which makes it good for going about your day.
But it’s a bit long and pointy which means if you’re having vaginal sex with it in it might poke the penis as it’s going past.
You can always trim the edge with fabric scissors though, and honestly, I’m just nitpicking so I don’t have to say that it’s perfect.
Pro Tip: Type in SEXUALALPHA20 upon checkout on Tantus for a 20% off discount.
Best Butt & Anal Plugs for Experts
Already know everything there is to know about anal play? Maybe you’re looking to step up your booty game and expand your horizons.
If that’s the case then try one of these expert-mode plugs.
The b-Vibe Triplet beads are USB-rechargeable vibrating anal beads that are a friendly place to start with beads, but also perfect if you’re looking to upgrade.
It has three beads ranging from small (0.8”) to about medium (1.2”) in diameter. If you’re a veteran of putting things in your butt that might seem too small to be “expert mode”.
BUT the vibrations and bead design make up for it.
Those two motors in the larger beads deliver some incredible vibrations that feel like they’re coming from every direction at once.
The Triplet really shines as a toy for straight couples. Having it inserted during vaginal sex means both partners can feel those vibrations for an intense session.
OR use it while outside with the wireless remote control for kinky public teasing. There’s a lot of options.
And if you want something with even more challenge, b-Vibe also offers the Cinco, which has 5 beads instead of three. Not really beginner-friendly, but even more to play with!
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, b-Vibe Triplet Anal Beads is on sale for $98 (from $140).
It’s hard to get your head around just how big 10 inches is.
Obviously, the American Bombshell B-10 Tango is not for the faint of heart or fragile of constitution.
The B-10 will fill you up and stretch you out and still have inches to spare!
This behemoth is made of PVC with a softer outer surface. Many toys this size are either too hard or too soft, but the B-10 manages to get the balance just right to satisfy most gape enthusiasts.
The Vac-U-Lock compatible base is a nice touch and might be essential for those of you brave enough to attempt all three bulges. It might be easier to lower yourself onto it than to put it in yourself.
And of course, it should be obvious, but use A TON OF LUBE every time.
Friendly PSA: At the time of publishing this article, American Bombshell B-10 Tango is on sale for $24.99 (from $50).
The dimensions of the b-Balls Duo aren’t particularly scary. 1.4 inches is pretty average for a butt plug and even novices shouldn’t have too much trouble inserting it.
But the feeling? That’s some advanced-level stuff.
Just like Kegel balls, the two plastic spheres contain weighted ball bearings that roll around and create an unpredictable feeling of movement in your butt.
It feels amazing when you leave it in and move around, or during sexy time. Basically, the more you move the better they feel! How awesome is that?
Those grooves make it interesting to look at, but on the other hand, they make the b-Balls Duo a little harder to clean.
It’s not the end of the world though — the materials are all body-safe and non-porous, so you can sterilize it by boiling or soaking in a 10% bleach solution.
And a few extra minutes of cleaning is worth it to feel that unique rumbling restless sensation whenever you take a step.
If you’re from the US, make sure you’re on the US site (us.funfactory.com) not EU site (en.funfactory.com) so Fun Factory doesn’t redirect you to the homepage.
Tips On Wearing Butt & Anal Plugs
If you’re new to butt plugs (and even if you’re experienced), there are a few tips that can help make your play session the best it can be.
First, make sure you’re nice and relaxed. Getting yourself aroused before you start inserting the butt plug will go a long way to helping you relax your butt muscles.
Like any play that involves penetration, lube is your best friend.
In fact, that’s even more accurate regarding anal play since, unlike a vagina, your butt doesn’t create its own lubricant.
Thick lubes with a gel-like consistency tend to be better for anal play – don’t be afraid to use a generous amount!
Make sure you choose a lube that’s compatible with the materials of your butt plug. I recommend a water-based lube to be safe since it’s compatible with any material.
When you’re ready to insert the plug, push it in gently and slowly. It’s natural to feel some resistance, but you should never force it, especially if it feels painful.
Concentrate on relaxing your sphincter and try different positions to find what works best for you (check out these sex positions for anal play). On all fours, or on your back with your knees raised to your chest are two popular positions.
If you still have trouble or feel any pain or discomfort, a smaller plug might be a better option.
What To Look For When Buying A Beginner Butt Plug
It’s easy to feel lost when you start looking at buttplugs. It seems simple at first but then an hour later you’ve compared 98 plugs and you have a headache.
Don’t worry. Like using a buttplug, shopping for one is better if you relax.
I’m going to take you through the most important aspects of butt plug selection to help you decide.
What are you planning to use it for?
If you’re brand new to this, it might be hard to answer the question. But it’s important.
Butt plugs are good for lots of things. If you know what you want it to do, that should point you in the right direction.
- All-day or long-term butt plug to wear in public: Do you want a plug you can discreetly keep wearing all day at the office or when you’re out and about? You’ll need something with a long neck, a comfortable T-base that doesn’t poke anywhere and not too big.
- Stretching/preparation for anal sex: look for something that has a wide neck. Length isn’t that important and neither are special features like vibrating. Look for plugs that say “stretching” in the description.
- Plug for wear during sex/ double penetration: You’ll want something that’s not too big (filling two holes at once can be uncomfortable). If it has a T-base, make sure it’s not too wide or it can poke your partner’s penis (annoying). I’d choose a rounded base over a T-base in this scenario.
- Just for pleasure/p-spot stimulation: If you have a prostate, look for dedicated p-spot massagers that will hit it exactly right. It’s best to learn your own anatomy with a finger first. And if you don’t have a prostate, then anything goes, really. Consider what you like about anal play and go from there!
Plugs can be made out of a lot of materials, but only three are really fit for their purpose.
- Silicone: The most comfortable for long-term wear. Also the most affordable body-safe option. It has vibrating options.
- Glass: Has lots of qualities that of steel at a very affordable price tag. Not so many shapes available though (but look into Icicles).
- Stainless Steel: Looks sexy, feels great for pressing the right buttons. Heavy. Expensive. Indestructible. It can be used with silicone lube that lasts for a long time. Can be bundled with a lube shooter.
- Generally, anything else is a NO. Soft plastics or metal alloys might feel good, but it’s not worth the risk of infections or metal splinters (yikes).
For other great options, see our best anal sex toy guide.
T-shaped or flared bases are an absolute must.
Your plug needs a wide base to stop it from being sucked in all the way.
Anyway, flared base or T-base?
T-bases are often better for public use since they sit in the butt crack and are less visible under clothes.
It’s really up to you. If you want a plug for double penetration then it’s often better to use a round flared base.
Smaller than you think you can take. If you can take two fingers in there, get a plug that’s smaller than that.
And work your way up in increments. For example, if you can take a 1.25” plug no problem, you can take a 1.5” plug with some relaxation and lots of preparation.
BUT 1.75” is gonna be too much. Work your way up slowly.
Butt plugs come in pretty much any design you can think of. Most, of course, are based on the classic cone-shaped design. But there are plenty of extra design features to look out for.
If you want extra sensations, there are textured options like the Lovense Hush. Or, if you’re feeling animalistic, there’s a whole range of pet play tail butt plugs to choose from.
There are also some cute and bejeweled options like the Pipedreams Icicles No 48 with its glass flower design or the sparkling Swarovski crystal of the Haka Pretty Plug.
Some vibrating butt plugs can even be controlled from a distance, either with a remote or a phone app. If you’re into public play, this could make your next trip to the grocery store much more fun.
If you want strong vibrations or favor rumbly over buzzy vibes, read some reviews or try to get an in-store demo.
Literally, the last thing anyone wants is to have a butt plug break off inside them during a rough play session. To avoid such a disaster, make sure your butt plug is made from durable materials.
The best way to do this is to buy from reputable brands and read user reviews.
Stay away from anything containing phthalates. Luckily, most good-quality sex toys no longer use these chemicals in their materials, but it always pays to double-check.
Some butt plugs are better for temperature play, for example, with some even having the ability to warm up. Others might include a storage bag or lube in the package.
Frequently Asked Questions About Butt & Anal Plugs
My Butt / Anal Plug Got Sucked In, What Should I Do?
If you’re using a toy specifically designed for anal play, this shouldn’t be a problem. The flared base is designed to avoid exactly this.
If you have somehow found yourself in this situation, you can try to relax your muscles and pull it out with your thumb and forefinger.
If you can’t manage to get it out yourself, though, it’s time for a trip to the emergency room.
Check out our guide about how to remove butt plug stuck In anus for more info.
How Long Can I Wear A Butt / Anal Plug?
If you’re really into anal play and wearable toys, it might be tempting to leave your butt plug in for extended periods of time. This can be a really bad idea, though.
Having your rectal lining squeezed up against a butt plug all day can cause ulcers to form, and you do not want that. Play it safe and restrict your butt plug use to two or three hours at most.
How To Clean an Anal Plug?
Before and after use, clean your plug with warm soapy water and mild antibacterial soap. For toys with electronic parts, check the manufacturer’s instructions.
How To Store A Butt Plug?
Make sure your toy is completely dry before storing it. Air-drying on a clean towel is the best way to ensure this.
Keep your butt plug in its own bag out of direct sunlight to protect it and your other toys. Check out this article for best practices in storing sex toys.
Well done for sticking around to the end! Hopefully I’ve helped clear up some of the confusion around buying and using a butt plug.
Now get out there and… get in there, I guess.