10 Best Fisting Lubes & Creams For Anal And Vaginal Play [2024]

Best Fisting Lube

First Look: Top 10 Best Fisting Lube & Creams For Anal And Vaginal Play

If you’re looking for a quick peek, check out my top fisting lube & creams for anal and vaginal play. But if you want the full scoop with reviews, feel free to keep scrolling down.

  1. Best Numbing Fisting Lube: Master Series Invade
  2. Best For Vaginal And Anal Fisting: TitanMen Triple Duty
  3. Best Warming Lube For Fisting: Elbow Grease Lube
  4. Best Hybrid Fisting Lube: Sliquid Naturals Silk
  5. Long Lasting Fisting Lube: Crisco
  6. Best Water Based Fisting Lube: J-Lube
  7. Hypoallergenic Silicone Fisting Lube: Astroglide X
  8. Best Fisting Lube For Silicone Toys: Boy Butter
  9. Best Thick Fisting Lube: Gun Oil
  10. Best Water-based Alternative Fisting Lube: Sliquid Organics

You mean, there’s lube specifically for fisting purposes? What makes it different?

Fisting lube or cream is (or at least should be) a little thicker than your average lube. That’s because fisting involves a ton of stretching, and you want it to go as smoothly as possible.

So what is fisting?

Here’s a neat definition:

“Fisting is the sexual act of inserting a hand, arm, or foot into the vagina or anus.

What vaginal or anal lube and stretching cream work the best for fisting, though?

That’s what I’m going to talk about in this fisting lubricant guide as well as different types of fisting lubes:

Top Anal And Vaginal Fisting Lubricants

BEST NUMBING FISTING LUBE
Master Series Invade

Master Series Invade

  • An excellent option for fisting
  • It can numb bodily discomfort
  • Fragrance-free
  • Suitable for vegetarians
  • Type: Oil-based numbing cream
BEST FOR VAGINAL AND ANAL FISTING
TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream

TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream

  • Affordable
  • Easy to use
  • It can get super-slick for extended periods
  • Fragrance-free and Hypoallergenic
  • Type: Hybrid (water + silicone) multi-purpose cream
BEST WARMING LUBE FOR FISTING
Elbow Grease Lube

Elbow Grease Lube

  • Creamy consistency
  • Provides heating sensations
  • Never drips or runs
  • Long-lasting, Fragrance-free, and Hypoallergenic
  • Type: Oil-based cream

fisting lube

Best Numbing Fisting Lube

1. Master Series Invade

PRICE:
$$
TYPE:
Oil-based numbing cream
LASTING POWER:
Unspecified
SCENT & TASTE:
Fragrance-free
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
No
SEX TOY SAFE:
No
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Unspecified
  • An excellent option for fisting
  • It can numb bodily discomfort
  • Not compatible with latex condoms
  • It may cause you not to notice tears

One of the perks of numbing cream is that it helps you relax more. After all, there won’t be as much pain, so your body automatically loosens up knowing this.

But as great as that sounds, it comes with a serious downside.

If you can’t feel pain, you can’t feel when your body is being stretched too far. Pain exists for a reason, after all: to tell you when something’s wrong.

So it’s generally not recommended to use numbing fisting creams and lubes.

But if you’re still willing to give them a go, then MasterSeries Invade deep-fisting cream would be a wise pick.

It’s a quality product, and it’s suitable for vegetarians. This is a good all-around deep-fisting cream despite the inherent problem with numbing lubes.

It’s slippery as all hell and lasts more than long enough.

Pro Tip

Use my discount code ALPHA15 to get 15% off on purchases from Lovehoney.


best lube for fisting

Best For Vaginal and Anal Fisting

2. TitanMen Triple Duty Fisting Cream

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Hybrid (water + silicone) multi-purpose cream
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Fragrance-free
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
Yes
SEX TOY SAFE:
Yes
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Yes
  • Affordable
  • Easy to use
  • It can get super-slick for extended periods
  • May need constant reapplication

Also, a solid pick for vaginal and anal fisting lubes alike. You can use it safely with condoms.

One thing that you’ll really appreciate is that it has a simple pump on the bottle. That makes reapplying so much easier when your hands are already lubed up.

Since it’s largely water-based, you need to use a little more of it. That said, it starts out creamier but slowly becomes more watery. 

It works amazingly for smoothing out the starting part of your fisting. And after a while, it’s nice and silky.


best lube for anal fisting

Best Warming Lube for Fisting

3. Elbow Grease Lube

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Oil-based cream
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Fragrance-free
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
No
SEX TOY SAFE:
No
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Yes
  • Creamy consistency
  • Provides heating sensations
  • Never drips or runs
  • Not compatible with condoms and sex toys

Adding temperature in your fisting play really spices things up! The Elbow Grease Lube is a mineral oil-based lubricant that’s so slippery and long-lasting. It’s infused with menthol that gives you a warming feeling.

That makes cleaning it quite tricky, though. But it’s one I don’t mind sacrificing (and don’t think about, TBH) as I’m enjoying the good sensations. Also, it easily slides right in when using this lube.

It has a creamy consistency that doesn’t run or drip—it stays exactly where you applied it. It also doesn’t get tacky, which you’d appreciate during fisting.

As this lube is oil-based, it’s not safe for latex, condoms, and sex toys. But if you’re only going to use this lube for fisting, then you shouldn’t have to worry.


fisting cream

Best Hybrid fisting ube

4. Sliquid Naturals Silk

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Hybrid (water + silicone) lube
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Very mildly citrusy & slightly lemony
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
Yes
SEX TOY SAFE:
Safe to use with some silicone toys
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Yes
  • Compatible with sensitive skin
  • Luxurious creamy texture
  • Affordable
  • Not compatible with all silicone toys

Perhaps the best lube for vaginal fisting you’ll find on the market.

What makes this hybrid lubricant particularly great is that it works so well for sensitive skin. It has cream emollients and natural ingredients that don’t “rub” the skin the wrong way.

The color makes it look a lot like cum. But how it feels and smells will probably put images of beauty products in your mind instead.

It has 12% silicone, so it mostly acts like a water-based lube with a touch of silky sleekness. That makes it the best lubricant for anal sex or fisting. It’s even condom-compatible.

It also has a pleasant yet mild citrusy smell as a nice cherry on top. A great lube overall.

Pro Tip

Use my discount code ALPHA15 to get 15% off on purchases from Lovehoney.


best anal fisting lube

Long Lasting Fisting Lube

5. Crisco

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Oil-based vegetable shortening
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Neutral & bland
EDIBLE:
Yes
CONDOM SAFE:
No
SEX TOY SAFE:
No
HYPOALLERGENIC:
No
  • Long staying power
  • Edible
  • Slick
  • Not compatible with latex condoms

For many, it is the main ingredient for the most delicious of fisting sessions.

Something fisting fans really appreciate about Crisco is its staying power. Since it’s basically just fat, your skin won’t absorb it any time soon.

Some people find the smell a bit off-putting. I personally never had a problem with it. And the cream’s sheer effectiveness as a lubricant far outweighs the aroma some may dislike.

Once rubbed wherever you need it rubbed, it will provide a wonderfully slick glide for ages

Here’s a tasty, kinky tip:

Roll up balls of Crisco and put them in the freezer for 5-6 hours. Once you take them out, they’ll be hard enough to put up your ass.

As it melts away in there, you’ll slowly get more lubed up.

Unrefined coconut oil is another great DIY anal lube you can just pick up at your local store. Aside from coconut oil, here are other homemade anal lubes you can try.


best lube for vaginal fisting

best water-based fisting lube

6. J-Lube

PRICE:
$$
TYPE:
Concentrated powder
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Fragrance-free & flavourless
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
Yes
SEX TOY SAFE:
Yes
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Yes
  • You can customize its sleekness
  • Easy aftercare
  • Solution still requires mixing

While originally used for veterinary purposes, it became a shining example of the water-based anal fisting lube category.

A single bottle of this concentrated powder can create as much as 6 gallons of lubricant. 

Moreover, it’s so easy to make: add water and enjoy! 

Water makes the lube more slippery, so you can customize the “slick factor” to your taste. Some people even add oils like Crisco (more on it later) for extra-lasting power and thickness.

The ingredients are body-safe, too. Although It has sucrose, which can cause yeast infections, there’s so little of it that it’s hardly anything to worry about.

When it comes to using it, it’s as slippery and silky as water-based lubricants get. And since you can make a ton of it, feel free to pile on more whenever you feel it running out during your fisting sesh.

Once you’re done, you can easily clean it off with water. Adding salt will wash off the lube faster, but it can irritate sensitive parts of your body.


Best J-Lube Recipe?

Seeing that many consider it the best lubricant for fisting, figuring out the optimal way to prepare it is quite a hot topic.

The exact recipe will vary a bit depending on who you ask, but this one works the best for me.

Here are the ingredients:

  • 3 to 4 tablespoons of J-Lube
  • 450 to 500ml of boiling water
  • 1 to 1.5 tablespoons of natural coconut butter (de-scented) – seems to keep it from drying out too quickly
  • (optional) 4 to 6 drops of consumable clove oil

Simply mix the J-Lube powder and water together and microwave it until it’s smooth. Afterward, add the coconut butter and clove oil. 

Don’t stir it with a blender since it’s difficult to ensure it’s absolutely clean before using it.


fisting lubes

Hypoallergenic sILICONE Fisting Lube

7. Astroglide X

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Silicone-based lubricant
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Fragrance-free & flavourless
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
Yes
SEX TOY SAFE:
No
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Yes
  • Affordable
  • Great for water sex
  • Smooth and silky
  • Not compatible with sex toys

This lube makes a good combo of quality and affordability.

According to the advertising, it’s hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, latex-compatible, and tasteless, which makes it accessible.

Astroglide is quite slippery and silky, which makes it terrific for anal fisting. And just a smidge of it will last you for a long time (though it isn’t the most durable silicone lube out there). 

Even though the box claims it holds no odors, Astroglide does have an ever-so-slight tang reminiscent of moisturizer. 

That said, it’s mild, and washing the lube off is as easy as applying a bit of soapy water or wiping it off with a towel.


best fisting lubes

Best Fisting Lube For Silicone Toys

8. Boy Butter

PRICE:
$$
TYPE:
Organic blend
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Bitter
EDIBLE:
Yes
CONDOM SAFE:
No (latex)
SEX TOY SAFE:
Safe to use with some silicone toys
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Unspecified
  • Doesn’t stain
  • Easy to clean
  • Compatible with some silicone sex toys
  • Not compatible with latex condoms

Unfortunately, silicone toys are not compatible with many lubricants. However, count yourself lucky for my eighth pick on this list.

Ladies and gentlemen, I present to you the Boy Butter Original!

Coconut oil and an organic silicone blend are the primary ingredients in this oil-based lube. And, you’ve guessed it, from the components alone, this is one of the absurdly long-lasting options you can pick out for your anal and vaginal ventures. 

Despite its silicone ingredient, it’s still compatible with most sex toys. However, latex condoms are a no-go. Though, polyurethane condoms can be acceptable. 

This lube also doesn’t come in a liquid form. Rather, it resembles real butter, as the name suggests. 

As a result, it lasts a long time and is simple to maintain. And it also comes off easily using water. That makes it safe for the body and simple to clean up after potential spills.

It’s also relatively affordable, which is a plus. And when compared to other silicone lubricants, the price per ounce is significantly lower.

For other alternatives, you can also check out my roundup of the Best Anal Lube for long-lasting sex.


best fisting cream

Best Thick Fisting Lube

9. Gun Oil

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Silicone-based lubricant
LASTING POWER:
Long lasting
SCENT & TASTE:
Unspecified
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
Yes
SEX TOY SAFE:
No
HYPOALLERGENIC:
No
  • It goes a long way
  • Long-lasting
  • Not compatible with most silicone sex toys
  • Hard to clean

Going in using only your hands is never an ideal scenario. They’re dry; unless you’re a heavily sweaty person, you might cause unwanted friction on your sensitive regions.

Worse, it might also ruin the mood altogether. And because of this, Gun Oil is your ideal lubrication for a good jerk and fist session. 

This silicone-based lube is exceptionally long-lasting. And, without a doubt, you’ll be the first to tire out before it dries. 

I’m telling you, you won’t find the same velvety sensation with any other product.

That aside, I do not recommend using Gun Oil with silicone sex toys, and to top it off, never attempt to consume it orally.

Pro Tip

Use my discount code ALPHA15 to get 15% off on purchases from Lovehoney.


anal fisting lube

Best Water-based Alternative Fisting Lube

10. Sliquid Organics

PRICE:
$
TYPE:
Water-based lubricant
LASTING POWER:
Average
SCENT & TASTE:
Unspecified
EDIBLE:
No
CONDOM SAFE:
Yes
SEX TOY SAFE:
Yes
HYPOALLERGENIC:
Unspecified
  • Vegan-friendly
  • It can function as a skincare product
  • Compatible with toys and condoms
  • Dries up quicker
  • It is not as long-lasting

If you’re looking for one of the best lubricants for fisting, Sliquid Organics is perhaps the most excellent water-based alternative you can go for. 

Since Organics is water-based, you can use any sex toy and condom with it.

And if you want to explore more on your sexual adventures, this lube is also a versatile option to cater to your needs. 

Compared to water-based lubes it has a slightly greater thickness. However, it dries up more quickly than the other listed options. 

As a note: Remember to reapply, if necessary, whenever you’re doing any sexual activity with this lubricant. 

Green tea, flaxseed, sunflower seeds, and aloe vera are just a few botanical components in Sliquid Organics. It’s fantastic for your skin and cruelty-free for vegans, so it’s a win-win!

To explore other natural options, check out my list of the 10 Best Lubes for Handjobs.


Why Use Fisting Lubes?

anal fisting cream

Fisting lubes are designed for people who are planning to do fisting activities. Also, it gives comfort to the person who is getting fisted. Fisting can give your body a lot of stress, and without appropriate lubrication, it can cause injury or discomfort.

These lubes are much more thicker and last longer than the regular lubricants that I use for regular sex; these fisting lubes can resist intense friction and stretching with fisting.


Types Of Fisting Lubes

vaginal fisting lube

You can use various types of lubes for fisting, depending on personal taste and what’s compatible with your body. Here are some common types:

Hybrid Lubes

These lubes mix the best of both worlds. They’re long-lasting, easy to clean, and play nice with latex and most toys. It’s like they’re the ultimate peacemakers, satisfying everyone.

They’re water-based fisting lubes with a dash of silicone, perfect for both bedroom activities. The silicone brings that extra slickness. Hybrids have just a bit, so they’re cool with silicone toys like fisting dildos.

They’ve got the perks of both worlds: super slippery, nice and thick, and won’t mess with your skin. It’s a win-win!


Water-based Lubes

best anal lube for fisting

Water-based lubes are the go-to choice for fisting – anal or vaginal. They’re safe with latex and all toys, but they might dry up quicker, so you might need to reapply. They’re nice and thick, even though they can get sticky. The cool part is that they’re easy to clean, won’t irritate your skin, and work well with condoms, latex gloves, and fisting sex toys.


Silicone-based Lubes

Silicone lubes are super slick and last a long time. They are safe for latex condoms but may not be compatible with silicone sex toys – since the lube corrodes them. 

Cleanup’s a bit of a hassle, especially on your sheets, as it’s hard to clean the stains it makes on your sheets, so be careful with it. Have a rag, towel, or makeup removal tissue handy to make the post-fisting cleanup easier.


Oil-based Lubes

fisting lub

These lubes are thick and go the distance, perfect for long-lasting action, especially in the backdoor department. But there’s a catch: don’t use them with latex condoms; they don’t play nice. They’re fantastic for solo fun or non-latex condoms.

This power comes with a price, though. Namely, they’re more difficult to clean away. It isn’t impossible by any means, though: just use soapy water, and you’ll be set nine times out of ten.

In most cases, oil-based lube and creams are hypoallergenic and won’t cause irritations. Avoid using them with latex, though, since they break it down. Oil-based lubes can trap bacteria and might not be the best if you tend to have vaginal infections.


Numbing Lubes

Numbing lubes, also known as desensitizing lubes or numbing agents, are lubricants that contain lidocaine, benzocaine, or other topical anesthetics. These ingredients temporarily numb the genitals or anus. 

The purpose of numbing lubes is to help people who may experience discomfort or pain during sexual activities, which in this case is anal fisting.

But with all that jazz, I always need to be mindful in every sexercise I do. With that, speak and pay attention to their body as numbing lubes, from the word numbing, can numb any pain and discomfort.


How to Pick the Best Fisting Lube

best fisting lubricant

You know when buying expensive clothes? I always try to consider every factor if it’s worth it. It’s the same with buying a fisting lube, now because I don’t want you to have a hard time, I’ve gathered all the important tips here:

Consistency

Fisting requires a lube with a thicker and more long-lasting consistency than regular sexual lubricants. Look for lubes designed explicitly for fisting, often labeled as “thick” or “extra thick.” These lubricants provide better cushioning and reduce friction during intense play.


Extra Features

There are lubes that have additional features that can enhance your fisting sessions! For example, you may find lubes with numbing agents to help reduce discomfort or anal relaxants to ease muscle tension.

Pro Tip

These lube need caution whenever you use them for your sexercise, as they could pain your partner, so always follow the instructions!


Avoid Harmful Ingredients

When choosing any sexual lubricant, including fisting lubes, avoiding harmful ingredients that may cause irritations or allergic reactions is crucial. Look for lubes free from parabens, glycerin, and fragrances, as these can potentially irritate sensitive skin.

Opt for water-based or silicone-based lubes, as they are generally safe and compatible with most body types.

Note: Always do a patch test with every product new lube you buy so you’ll know if it suits your skin.


How To Use Fisting Lubes Or Creams? 

best lubes for fisting

If you’re just dipping your toes/fingers into the realm of fisting, you should know how to use the vaginal or anal fisting cream and lube correctly.

Here are the most vital tips to keep in mind.

Use Plenty Of It

The first thing to keep in mind is to never be stingy with the slippery stuff. 

Good lubrication will make fisting so much more comfortable. And the best way to keep your fisting session running smoothly is to be generous with the lube you apply.

“Too much” won’t be a concern for you here.


Apply To Both The Giving Hand/foot And The Receiving Hole

The best idea would be to apply the cream or lube on both the inserter and the insertee. That should ensure that there’s minimal friction between the areas in contact.

Spread the lubricant thoroughly on the limb going inside to get rid of any “grippy” areas.


Use Gloves

Gloves come in very handy during fisting. That’s because they cover up the skin of the hand, especially the fingernails.

If you wear gloves, the risk of scratching the inner walls of the vagina or anus goes way down.

Keep in mind that not all lubes work with all gloves, though! For example, oil-based ones break down latex gloves, which makes them tear faster. 

On the other hand, water-based lubes are fine for any glove.


Have A Towel Ready

With all this lube in the mix, you can expect the situation to get very sloppy and wet very quickly.

If you aren’t up for a lengthy cleanup, put some towels down to catch all the dropped lube.


..And A Few Fisting tips

best lube for pussy fisting

For a little extra, consider the following fisting pointers.

Go Slow!!!

Anal or vaginal fisting is not something you immediately do with your partner. 

Nine times out of ten, there will be at least 30 minutes of stretching and foreplay before the main show.

So take your time, be patient, and ensure the receiver is perfectly relaxed before making big moves.

If they have a vagina, you can rub their clit while penetrating to get them into it.


Fingers First, Fist For Later

It’s best to penetrate with your fingers first and work your way in. You may want to consider checking out my guide about how to finger a pussy.

Don’t make a fist until the hand is entirely inside.

Trimming your fingernails is also a good idea if you’re the giver. You don’t want to scratch or scrape your partner’s insides and risk giving them an infection.


Use Sex Toys

Incorporating sex toys into fisting can enhance pleasure and make the experience more enjoyable for some individuals.

However, it is crucial to choose toys designed explicitly for fisting.

For reference, check out my articles on the Best Anal Training KitsBig Huge Dildos, and Thickest Dildos you can use.

As for specific toys and recommendations, you might want to check out any of these three:

lube fisting

Mr. Hankey’s Cyrus King

This thick dildo, modeled after pornstar Cyrus King, comes in four sizes ranging from a moderate 7 to a gigantic 13 inches. It’s as thick as it is wide!

I appreciate the effort put into the little details. This big dildo was clearly made with a lot of love, and it shows in the tiny details everywhere. 

Also, it WORKS with a harness! So what more could you want?


best fisting gel

Mr. Hankey’s Goliath

Mr. Hankey’s Goliath is all about the stretch! And trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this one. 

If the sight of a natural penis stimulates you, this is the finest example available.

This dildo is insane in its details. The veins are pretty lifelike, complete with a very gentle texture. And when taken internally, its bulk makes for a pleasant sensory experience.


best vaginal fisting lube

CalExotics Anal Kit

If you are new to Anal Fisting or have been away for too long, the CalExotics Anal Training Butt Plug Kit could help you with your stretching exercise.


Other People’s Tips & Experience

Lube, lube, and more lube…

I’ve found that a well-lubed hand, getting things pretty close, then pulling it out, reapplying lube, then carrying on… this really helps.

Ensure that he’s not trying to make an actual fist until his hand is fully inside of you (i.e., he’s in up to his wrist). Until then, he should be in the “duck bill” position with his hand, with his thumb tucked as far as possible behind his fingers.

You need to be really aroused – I find that licking my wife’s clit while working my hand in is helpful. I won’t let her cum until my fist is inside, but I get her really wanting it.

He may find success with a bit of a twisting motion towards the end; it seems to help work things in way better than just forcing pressure in.

Finally… he can’t be overly gentle. When he gets it close, the key is to just go with it…

alittlebirdy1

Reddit User

“Make sure you are really aroused and use lots of lube. I would recommend him wearing gloves and taking it slow. You can buy big dildos to use on your own/together to slowly get used to taking larger objects.

You can also try fisting yourself (your hand is probably smaller), but the angle can be impossible/uncomfortable.”

Arie_R

Reddit User

Massage the perineum prior, which can help increase elasticity in the tissue. Go soooo slow. Make a “duck bill” shape with the hand doing the fisting once the time has come to go past the knuckles.

Use so much more lube than you think you need. Too much is almost enough!

Try different positions to determine the most comfortable for the recipient. Communication is key! And there will likely be a sort of burning sensation when you’re really stretched, but and sharp feeling is bad, bad, bad!

Ask them to wait and let you adjust to the sensation as you stretch. Be super gentle. And most importantly, communication, lube, go slow, and enjoy yourselves.”

crackwhorebarbie

Reddit User


Have fun!

That wraps up my breakdown of the best fisting lubricant options!

Now you know what kinds of anal lube and stretching creams are out there. Better yet, you know which ones will better suit your fisting needs.

You may also want to consider checking out my guide on the best sexual lubricant for more options.

I hope you’ll enjoy your sexercise stretching! 😉

Dainis Graveris

Dainis Graveris

Over last 4 years Dainis have helped millions of people through his advice on this site (200+ guides and 1M+ visits/monthly). His work & advice has appeared on sites like: Healthline, Vice, Cosmopolitan, Men's Health, WomensHealthMag, MindBodyGreen & more. Read More.

Got Questions? Ping me on Twitter.