6 Best Metal Butt Plugs in 2024 (Large & Stainless Steel)

Stainless steel butt plugs offer butt fun you can’t get from softer plugs. That’s why we did all the HEAVY work to give you the best metal butt plugs of 2024.

best metal butt plugs

Metal is not just for bands like Metallica or your aesthetic Hydro Flask. They’re for butt plugs too! These are not your moving plugs like vibrating anal plugs or your thrusting butt plugs!

Metal butt plugs offer sensations in your anal fun unique from butt plugs made in softer materials. They’re rigid, great for temperature play, and ideal for targeted stimulation. In other words, you should try them.

Don’t know where to start? We’ve got your back (pun intended).

Here are our top three picks:

SexualAlpha Top Pick

NJoy Pure Plug has a bulbous head that would stretch you, a tapered tip that makes insertion easy, and a curved stem to stimulate your internal hotspots. In other words, it ticks all the boxes you should look for in a metal butt plug. Plus, it has a finger loop to give you more control and easy handling of the plug.

Budget Pick

Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug is easy on the pocket and easy to insert. Start with it or size up as it has three size options for beginners to anal players who want a larger anal plug. And it looks pretty when plugged into your butt, thanks to its jeweled base.

Upgrade Pick

Nexus Cestos is a metal butt plug that brings your anal play to the next level with vibrations. Yep, it’s a vibrating metal anal plug with 6 vibrations modes to combine targeted stim and rumbling vibes. It’s remote-controlled for a wireless fun solo or with a partner.


Top 3 Metal Butt Plugs In 2024

Budget Pick

metal buttplugs

Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug

SexualAlpha Top Pick

metal buttplugs

NJoy Pure Plug

Upgrade Pick

metal buttplugs

Nexus Cestos

Material:
Zinc-alloy
Stainless steel
Aluminum
Insertable length:
2.5”
2.25”
4”
Width:
1.19”
1”
1.59”

The Best Metal Butt Plugs In 2024

metal anal plugs

SexualAlpha Top Pick

1. nJoy Pure Plug

Price:
$$
Material:
Stainless steel
Length:
Not specified
Insertable length:
2.25”
Width:
1”
Size options:
3
  • Large head + weighted for stretch and fullness
  • Handle loop for easy hold
  • Easy to insert with its tapered tip
  • Could be used for extended wear
  • Quite pricey

njoy is one of the best stainless steel sex toy manufacturers—from their well-designed toys to the good build and quality. Pure Plug is no exception.

Pure Plug has a large head. But it’s still easy to insert, thanks to its tapered, angled head. Its curved body does great at stimulating your prostate. Plus, the slim stem makes it comfortable for long-time use.

I also like how the Pure Plug has a finger loop to give you more control in thrusting and helps in inserting in or pulling out of your bumhole.

Its size is safe for beginners and has larger sizes for a fuller feeling.

It’s not the most affordable metal butt plug as it’s made from medical-grade stainless steel. But for its build, quality, and beautifully crafted design, I’d say this one bags the best value for your money.


stainless steel anal plugs

Budget Pick

2. Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug

Price:
$
Material:
Zinc-alloy
Length:
3”
Insertable length:
2.5”
Width:
1.19”
Size options:
3
  • Very affordable
  • Weighted for a full feeling
  • Tapered tip for easy insertion
  • Not made from stainless steel

Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Butt Plug is many people’s go-to budget metal anal plug. It’s very affordable but does the job and does it well.

It’s small and tapered, making it easy to insert even for beginners. But despite its intimidating size, it has a nice girth (1.19” in diameter) and weight (145 grams) that provides a filling sensation.

You might find it too small for you, though. Don’t worry, as you can size up with its two bigger versions with an insertable length of 3 inches and 3.5 inches.

This jeweled metal plug isn’t made from stainless steel; thus, it’s affordable. However, it’s made from nickel-free zinc-alloy, so it’s safe for people with sensitive skin.


stainless steel anal toys

Upgrade Pick

3. Nexus Cestos Metal Remote Control Rechargeable Vibrating Butt Plug

Price:
$$$
Material:
Aluminum
Length:
5”
Insertable length:
4”
Width:
1.59”
Size options:
1
  • 6 vibration modes
  • Remote-controlled vibes
  • Ribbed shaft for extra stimulation
  • Expensive

What better way to upgrade your butt plug fun than by adding some vibrations?

Nexus Cestos brings your anal play fun to the next level. It gives you the sensations you can expect from a metal butt plug: precise stimulation in your internal pleasure points.

Then, it ups the ante by adding vibration. You can play around with its 6 vibration modes to add variety and find the best intensity for you. It’s remote-controlled, so you won’t have to worry about fumbling the buttons. You may even have your partner control the vibrations for you from across the room. 

With all those combined, Nexus Cestos does come with a hefty price tag. But all the pleasure it gives is worth every cent.


stainless steel anal plug

Best for Roleplay

4. DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Medium Faux Silver Fox Tail Butt Plug

Price:
$
Material:
Stainless steel
Length:
19” (including tail)
Insertable length:
3”
Width:
1.35”
Size options:
1
  • For roleplaying and furry kinks
  • Soft faux fur tail
  • Teardrop-shaped, manageable size
  • Only comes in one size

DOMINIX Deluxe Faux Silver Fox Tail Butt Plug is for the vixen who’s into roleplaying and furry kinks.

The butt plug is weighted and teardrop-shaped for easy insertion. 

But the soft and bushy faux fox tail really stands out and unleashes your inner beast. It feels good against your skin as it glides on your butt cheeks and thighs. And it looks so sexy when worn.

This anal toy only comes in one size. I suggest this for anal players who are looking to enhance visual stimulation than just sensation alone, as it might be small for some.

For more options, check out this list of tail butt plugs.


metal anal plug

Best Large Metal Anal Plug

5. njoy Pure Plug 2.0 XL Stainless Steel Butt Plug

Price:
$$$
Material:
Stainless steel
Length:
5.5”
Insertable length:
3.5”
Width:
2”
Size options:
1
  • Large size and weighted for FULL feeling
  • Oversized handle for control
  • Expensive

njoy Pure Plug 2.0 is, as its name, the 2.0 of Pure Plug. Sometimes, bigger IS better.

Pure Plug 2.0 follows all the good things that Pure Plug did right, then sized it up. It has a wider diameter, longer insertable length, and heavier weight. 

The weight is 600 grams, which is really hefty. It will weigh down when you wear it (as that’s how gravity works), which adds filling sensations and more stimulation.

It is EXPENSIVE, but it’s worth it if you want to go bigger. When you go big, you can’t go back.


stainless butt plugs

Best for Beginners

6. Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Tapered Butt Plug

Price:
$
Material:
Zinc-alloy
Length:
3.5”
Insertable length:
3”
Width:
1.27”
Size options:
1
  • Small, tapered tip
  • Affordable
  • Only one size

Lovehoney Jewelled Metal Tapered Butt Plug is the best for beginners. Its shape is not the usual teardrop. But it has a slimmer tip that stays pretty slim before gradually bulging, making it more manageable for anal newbies.

This tapered butt plug is weighted but not too heavy. It won’t feel overwhelming for first-timers. As it’s made for beginners, there’s only one size. 

Of course, you can easily go for other options when you’re ready to size up as this one’s very affordable anyway and won’t be a waste of money.


Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Metal Butt Plug

Body-safe metal

They can be made from different types of metal. Stainless steel is often the best material, but it’s quite expensive. Importantly, look for medical-grade and body-safe materials to ensure they’re safe to use in your most sensitive spots. 


Size

Going big doesn’t always have to be your end goal for pleasure. Remember: metal toys are very firm and pretty hefty. Even if it’s “small,” it’s still going to be very stimulating. Of course, it’s important to start small if you’re a beginner or go big if you’re more experienced.

Insertable length

The insertable length shows how far the toy can go inside you. And it can vary, for most going between 2.5 to 4 inches long. Beginners may want one that doesn’t go too far inside, whereas pros may be able to handle a “more extended” variety.


Circumference

The circumference refers to the diameter of the bulbous end that users would insert into their bodies. Smaller toys with a circumference of around 3 inches are an excellent option for beginners.

Meanwhile, more advanced options can measure up to 5 inches in length. And some even have a three-in-one package for users to experiment with different sizes.


Shape

If you’re just starting, choose a butt plug that has a teardrop shape and a tapered end, as it is the most beginner-friendly. And not only that, it is the easiest to put in and is most likely to stay intact when used.


Anal-safe

Metal butt plugs are made for butt play, so they should be safe. But what should you look for? The most important is a flared base or loop—it should be wider than the plug’s widest insertable part so it won’t get sucked in your bumhole.


Type of metal

Butt plugs can come from a variety of metals. Stainless steel, for example, is resilient and resistant to corrosion, so it is an excellent material overall.

But as a warning, some models can contain nickel, which causes allergic reactions in some individuals. So if you have this allergy, better avoid them and look for alternatives.


Base

There are four bases for metal butt plugs: round, O-ring, T-base, and flared base.

A round base can cause unwanted reactions, and the way it brushes against your cheeks can become irritating.

The T-base fits snugly into your crack, allowing you to walk with it or leave it in place for an extended period without discomfort.

In contrast, products with an O-ring base are suitable for attaching accessories such as a tail. And to add to that, the ring makes it simpler to remove the plug once anal play is over.

And finally, a flared base prevents the toy from being sucked into the anus while worn. The larger it is, the less likely this will occur; however, if it is too large, it may get uncomfortable for you to wear. Some flared varieties have a ring on their base to simplify inserting and removing the toy when necessary.


Texture

Numerous metal butt plugs feature additional knobs or ribs along the shaft. This extra texturing increases stimulation and pleasure along the nerve endings in the anal cavity. They can increase the overall sensation, so even shorter sessions by yourself or with a partner can become more enjoyable.


Designs

There are a variety of designs available, ranging from straight toys having singular bulbs to those with multiple ones for enhanced pleasure and orgasms.

There are also those curved products that can perfectly hit your prostate. And for variety, some models even have rings on their ends for easy holding, gems for a dazzling shine, and a tail to fill those furry fantasies in the bedroom.


Budget

You should consider how much you’re willing to spend on a metal butt plug, as the price range for these toys can vary between $20 to hundreds to even thousands of dollars.

Always purchase a high-quality item if you are a novice to avoid wasting money. In the future, more expensive metal butt plugs will be available. So with the numerous brands made accessible today, choose toys that are within your price range and suitable to your tastes.


Extra features

Butt plugs have few additional features beyond those discussed previously, so you should also be watchful with those.

The Nexus Cestos, for example, is equipped with an internal vibrator and a remote control for adjusting the settings. In addition, you can charge it using a magnetic USB cable to provide overall convenience.

Other features, such as jeweled bases or fluffy tails, can also add flair and spontaneity to your toy.


FAQs

What is a metal butt plug?

A metal butt plug is an anal sex toy that resembles a traditional butt plug but is made of metal, most commonly stainless steel, aluminum, or titanium. The material makes them denser, shinier, stiffer, sleeker, and more visually appealing than toys made of silicone.


Why use metal butt plugs?

These butt plugs are different from softer anal plugs because they offer more intense and targeted stimulation. It’s also great for temperature play—use it hot or cold! They are also nonporous, body-safe, very easy to clean, and durable as long as they’re made from good materials.


How to use a metal anal plug?

Your anus doesn’t lubricate like the vagina, so some added lubrication is essential when using a metal butt plug. Ample lubricant application makes the entire experience pleasurable and easier on the anus, thereby preventing painful muscle tears and potential infections.

Therefore, after applying lubricant to the plug and yourself, push the plug using its tapered tip to guide you. And when it feels excessively tight, stop moving and give those muscles time to adjust before continuing.

Once the heaviest part of the toy is inside, the hard part is complete. As with other sex toys, you may need to experiment with different positions and angles until you find the one that best suits your preference.

In addition to using more lubricant, it is helpful to relax beforehand by listening to soothing music, taking a bath, or even lighting some sexy candles in the bedroom.


Are metal butt plugs safe?

Yes, as long as you practice anal safety practices. How to ensure your anal play is safe? Make sure to answer Yes to all of the following:

  • Is it clean?
  • Is it made from body-safe metal?
  • Does it have a flared base?
  • Did you use lots and lots of lube?

What are the possible risks?

Anal play is only safe as long as you use them safely. But why should you? Here are some risks:

  • Burning sensation if there’s friction from the lack of lubricant
  • Discomfort if the plug is too big or lacks lube
  • Overstretching if you didn’t use the right size for you

What lube should you use with a metal butt plug?

A metal butt plug is generally safe to use with any lube like silicone and water-based lubricants. Still, check with the manufacturer on which lubes are safe to use for it.


How to clean and store metal butt plugs?

You can clean butt plugs made of stainless steel with mild soap and warm water. Ensure to remove all fluids and debris that have accumulated on the toy. And after, thoroughly dry and store in a bag or box until its subsequent use.


Are metal butt plugs rust-proof?

Whether or not anal plugs rust depends on their material and how they are maintained. Aluminum and stainless steel are rust-resistant, so they should not be the primary concern.

If you thoroughly clean and dry the toy before storing it, rust shouldn’t be a problem, even if the material is oxidize-prone.


Where to buy metal anal plugs online?

We recommend going to well-established retailers like Shevibe and Lovehoney. They sell a variety of high-quality sex toys with excellent customer service, a solid warranty, and a great return policy.


Conclusion

Oh, the joy of metal butt plugs.

Anal play gets an A score for sexplorations of any gender. If there are only two things to remember when choosing your toy, it should be 1) safe and 2) satisfying.

Aliyah Moore

Aliyah Moore

Aliyah Moore (she/her) is our resident sex expert at SexualAlpha. She’s a certified sex therapist with a Ph.D. in Gender & Sexuality Studies. Aliyah is a proud Black, bi-sexual femme passionate about empowering minority voices to embrace their sexuality and identity. She loves to write about everything sexual wellness and gives no-nonsense sex and relationship advice.

Got Questions? Ping me on Twitter.