It’s never been easier to unleash your inner animal during roleplay. Take a walk on the wild side with the sexiest animal tail butt plug.
Table of Contents
What Kind of Animal Do You Want to Be?
Deep in the kinky cauldron of animal roleplay bubbles endless possibilities.
With a super sexy animal tail butt plug, you can bound around the bedroom in the ultimate sultry safari. Or, obey your Master like the obedient little puppy you are.
Basically, these neat anal sex toys allow you to step into the paws (or claws, or hooves) of your favorite furry fetish.
You can be a feisty fox, a smirking, sexed-up kitty cat, a cute piggy or bunny, a ferocious dragon, or even a sweet little Pikachu. Yeah, seriously. A Pikachu.
Told you, the possibilities are endless.
You can check out the best butt plugs if you want something more traditional.
But if you are ready to unleash your inner beast, you’re in the right place.
Top Animal Tail Butt Plugs In 2022
White Fox Tail
Rainbow Pony Tail
More of a whole package kinda deal than just a butt plug, the ears are a cool addition to complete the look.
So, furry fetish friends, you can be the alpha of the pack or the runt of the litter with this matching two-piece ensemble. Whatever floats your kinky boat.
Glass is compatible with silicone based lubes, and you can still plug up comfortably. Also, it is completely body-safe and easy to clean!
Plus, the faux fur feels irresistible when it brushes against your thighs.
White foxes are notoriously cunning, not to mention rare. You can be a sexy, stalking winter fox with the White Fox Tail Vibrating Butt Plug from Frisky.
Although the vibrations might give you away…
This soft, swishy fox tail does the talking here. It’s theatrically long and wide, so you can have all kinds of foxy fun pulling the tail (which feels glorious inside you when you attach the removable vibrator, too) or just parading yo’ stuff in your bedroom/wildlife reserve.
There’s only one setting on the vibrator and it’s not the most powerful (think electric toothbrush), but as we said, it’s more about the aesthetic with this one.
Saddle-up, and go for a raunchy ride on your ranch with the Rainbow Pony Tail Butt Plug. Add a riding crop to punish any naughty behavior, and you’re good to go.
The flared base makes the tail plug feel super secure inside your anus, so you can buck, swish, and gallop to your heart’s content.
The smooth crystal slides in like a dream, and you can use a silicone based lubes if need be.
Plus, the total length is really long, so you can braid and style it.
It is synthetic hair, though, so over-styling won’t do its longevity much good (and avoid heating tools, girls and guys!), and it might get a little itchy with time.
Move over vanilla Catwoman Halloween costumes. This Cat Tail butt plug allows you to go even deeper into character…
With the anal plug being, well, a glass plug, it feels weighty and solid without being too heavy. It’ll stay inside you nicely while feeling quite indulgent and expensive.
Yes, you can be a kitty cat with class, even with your ass filled up.
For a luxurious Playboy Bunny-style treat for your anus, the Magnetic White Bunny Tail Plug by Crystal Delights is probably the most premium butt plug on our list.
The real rabbit fur on this (don’t worry, the company only uses byproduct fur – they do not condone cruelty) means it’s insanely soft and silky to the touch.
Definitely more on the innocent side of hardcore, the little anal plug and the fluffy white bunny tail give off a super angelic vibe. Plus, it’s perfect for feather-light touch play.
On the other hand…
This combo of Black Bunny Tail Plug is firmly in the darker realm of naughty with its BDSM aesthetic.
Kind of like if the Easter Bunny fucked the devil and they had a baby.
The relatively mini plug is easy to push into even a virgin butt, so you won’t need to warm up too much.
The super fluffy bunny tail doesn’t remove from the plug, so cleaning can be a bit taxing. However, you can use mild soap and a blow-dryer on it safely.
As Pokémon fans have grown up, so have their merchandise. Now, you’re as likely to find a Pokémon-themed tail butt plug as you are a Pokestop. And, your folks thought it was child-friendly! LOL.
With Pikachu being the pinnacle of all things cute, you can totally embody that cuteness by… yep, sticking a legit ‘Piky’ tail up your ass. Unorthodox? Maybe. But totally worth it.
Scoring 10/10 in the novelty category, this Piky butt plug adds 100x cuteness to any kinky Pokémon roleplay you may be partaking in.
The fox tail butt plug by LoveHoney could be perfect if you want to take your inner fox for a stroll (we all have one, truly).
The faux fur fox tail is attached to a steel butt plug. Thanks to the choice of sizes, the smaller plug can be newbie-friendly for those fox cubs out there.
Of course, if this ain’t your first rodeo, the larger size is better.
Plus, the swishy fox tail length has got some swing to it (which allows for some sassy strutting).
The Pig Tail butt plug is a pleasantly humiliating choice for your badly-behaved sub; make them squeal like the piggy they are!
Totally degrading; there’ll be no feathery feels to be had here. Getting on all-fours with your ass in the air and this little plug protruding out, you’ll feel like the dirtiest of pigs.
Of course, this differs from the softer, furrier options but definitely possesses its own unique appeal.
The all-over PVC is long-lasting, but it is still a porous material that cannot be fully sanitized. So, you should make sure you clean it thoroughly after each use.
Wanna get in the MOOO-d? Try plugging in this little buddy for some cowtastic coitus.
You can choose between a metal or silicone plug (metal or stainless steel is most popular- the feeling of cold metal sliding into your ass? Divine).
The tail is super cute with formidable length and, therefore, plenty of pulling potential. Plus, it’s long enough that the silky tip can be used creatively for touch-play on other body parts.
Put your dragon in its place with the Dragon Tail Butt Plug. How to Train Your Dragon, indeed!
Perhaps surprisingly, there’s no scaly texture on this dragon tail. In fact, it’s made from faux fur and is rather soft.
It’s got cute little spikes, so it looks the part, but in terms of pain-inflicting, it’s about as ferocious as a 3-week old kitten.
It’s super long, so it’ll get pleasingly tangled up in any legs present, creating a sensual trail of tingling in its path.
The Animal Tail Butt Plug Buying Guide
Not all furry tail butt plugs are created equal. To make sure you’re getting the right one and the best toy to suit your needs, here are a few things to pay attention to.
What’s the best size and shape?
Often, animal butt plugs focus more on the external tail than having an overly large plug.
However, the tail plug part is really the most important when it comes to your safety and comfort, as well as the sensations you’ll experience.
Most butt plugs will be bulbous and curved to match your inner anal walls. This will help to keep the butt plug in place, as well as make it comfortable.
You’ll also want to be sure the pointed tip of the plug is nicely rounded and super smooth. A butt plug that’s pointed but smooth is much easier to insert. Remember to relax your muscles and also use plenty of lube!
When it comes to the tail, you are completely free to select whichever anthropomorphic vibe you like!
Longer tails tend to give off a more sensual, pendulous appeal, while shorter, bunny, or pig-style tails are more cute and punchy.
In terms of the butt plugs: if you’re completely new to anal play, it probably goes without saying to start with something slender and shorter to ease yourself in.
A lighter tail could be more comfortable, too.
What are the best animal tail butt plug materials?
There are typically two options: real fur or fake (faux).
Of course, depending on your sentiments towards living, fluffy creatures, you may prefer to opt for faux fur. Fake fur tails are more cost-effective, however, the quality of your butt plug overall will not rival that of a real fur version.
Real fur is a little trickier to take care of but feels much softer and will last longer.
Generally speaking, you can opt for silicone, metal (usually stainless steel), or glass.
Silicone plugs tend to be more beginner-friendly, as it’s more flexible and can move with your body (although you can get rock-hard silicone, too). Best to check before purchasing!
For more seasoned butt pluggers, glass or metal are excellent for that weighty, solid feeling and are suitable for temperature play.
For those who want a little more aesthetics, you can check out our guide on the best jewel butt plug.
Plus, with the latter options, you’re free to use any type of lubricant, whereas silicone will require silicone-friendly lube (usually water-based).
Contrary to logic, silicone lubes actually destroy silicone sex toys!
There are so many amazing options on the market, so you can really let your imagination run wild!
I’d be willing to bet there’s a tail butt plug to match any animal you can think of, plus a bunch that doesn’t even exist! So if unicorn roleplay is your kink, I’ve got good news for you.
The color and design may not be a big deal to some, but they can affect how much excitement you get from it. So, take your time perusing all the different colors and designs before settling on one or two you’d like to try.
If you want a little extra kick in your roleplay, you can find butt plugs with some fun extra features. The most common (and most exciting, if you ask me) is the addition of vibrations in the plug itself.
You might not be the only one purring along in your next play session!
Another fun extra is poseable tails. You can find tails that include a bendable rod, so you can pose them to whichever position you want.
What are tail butt plugs?
If you’ve ever seen or used a butt plug before, you’ll know it’s a small sex toy designed to be inserted and worn anally. They have a very recognizable design – usually a cone shape with a flared base so it can be used safely and comfortably.
Now imagine that, but with an animal tail attached!
A tail butt plug combines all the anal pleasure of a regular butt plug plus the added thrill of primal or animal roleplay (or simply just the fun of trying something new).
An animal tail butt plug comes in literally hundreds of different designs, from short, curly piggy tails to long, luxurious fox tails and everything in between!
How to use tail butt plugs?
Like any anal play, it’s important to be relaxed and comfortable before you begin. Try to find a position where you can easily relax your sphincter muscles.
Use plenty of lube – it’s usually best to use thick gel-like lube for anal penetration since it lasts longer. Once you’re ready, slowly push the plug in until it’s ‘grabbed’ by your butt muscles.
All that’s left after that is to have fun!
How to use a tail butt plug in furry role play?
Once you’ve chosen your perfect animal tail butt plug, the furry fun can really start!
Embodying the characteristics of your chosen animal can be amazingly liberating and allow you to explore avenues you’ve never thought of.
Whether it’s a one-off fantasy or something that permeates your dreams on a nightly basis, we’ve got some ideas you’re going to love:
This one is a no-brainer. Of course, when you’re parading around like a super sexy little minx (no matter which animal you’re playing), your partner is going to want to fuck you.
With the plug inside you, it’s going to make your pussy feel way tighter. Obviously, this is excellent news for both him and you!
This can pretty much include any animal. It’s very BDSM (as is generally the nature of animal play!), as one partner plays the ‘owner’ and the other (wearing the tail) becomes the ‘pet.’
As a ‘pet,’ you’re under total control of your owner, and you must do everything they say. Of course, you can be a badly-behaved pet, too. But there might be consequences…
As much as you unleash your inner animal, you can leash up, as well. With a puppy tail butt plug and a leash, you can roleplay a puppy training session. Make sure there are all kinds of naughty treats as rewards for good behavior (as well as punishments, of course!).
As a wild animal, when you’re playing a foxy vixen, you don’t have to abide by the same rules a domesticated pet would follow!
This allows for much more biting, scratching, and general viciousness, which can be deliciously naughty.
What are the dos and donts of pet play Butt plugs?
There are a couple of simple things to keep in mind to make your experience with a tail butt plug the best it can be.
- Do use lube
Penetration is always better with lube, and that goes double for anal penetration! Make sure you invest in a good quality lube that’s compatible with the materials of your toy – that means water based lubes if your butt plug is silicone!
- Do keep it clean and dry in between sessions
Because of the furry nature of a tail butt plug, it’s really important to clean them thoroughly after you’re done.
The best way to do this is by hand, with mild soap and warm water. Make sure it’s completely dry before storing it away!
- Don’t wash your tail butt plug in a dishwasher or washing machine
It might be tempting to take the easy route when it comes to washing your new toy, but trust me, you don’t want to learn the hard way whether or not it’s dishwasher safe. That goes for washing machines too!
You could easily damage the tail butt plug or the machine. Just imagine, you’d have to wash your clothes by hand and couldn’t even relax with a nice pet play session afterward. Sounds like a special kind of hell.
- Don’t pull on the tail itself to remove it
Another quick way to damage your tail butt plug is by pulling on the tail. Most tails are attached with glue, so one tug too many could easily pull it off the plug.
Unless you want to be left with a regular butt plug and a questionable hair extension, always remove your tail butt plug by holding onto its flared base and pulling gently.
How do you choose the right tail plug for yourself?
- Know what you want
Like with any sex toy, you’ll get a lot further a lot faster if you know what you want before you start shopping.
If you’ve used butt plugs in the past, think about the size and shape you enjoyed the most. Do you like longer, thicker plugs for that full feeling? Or do you prefer the subtle sensations of a smaller plug? If you’re a beginner, consider starting with something small.
When it comes to the tail, try to narrow it down to one or two types and then browse in that category to find the one that gets your heart racing.
- Do your research
With so many different options out there, it can be hard to know where to begin. That’s why sex toy reviews are so helpful. Spend some time reading other user reviews and researching the materials, size, and shape of any butt plug you’re considering for yourself.
Knowledge is power, after all!
- Understand your body
It might be tempting to jump in and buy the first tail butt plug that tickles your fancy, with the hope that it will tickle some other things too. First, though, make sure you know your body’s needs.
There’ll be nothing but disappointment in store if you buy a jumbo-sized butt plug that your body just can’t accommodate. You don’t want to stick a large animal tail between your butt cheeks if you aren’t familiar with these anal sex toys. Next, find something comfortable for long term wear or a plug that you can wear for long periods. The same goes for materials – if you have sensitive skin (and even if you don’t), make sure you’re buying hypoallergenic materials.
At the end of the day, the only way to find out if that fox tail butt plug you’re been eyeing is right for you is to try it. There’s a balance between theory and practice – do your research, but eventually, you’ll need to turn to good old trial and error.
And remember, if the first tail butt plug you buy isn’t quite what you wanted, you can always try again!
Should I get a real or faux fur tail?
The choice is always up to you, but here are a few things about each to help you make your decision.
- Real fur
Real fur is much more luxurious and, well, realistic. It’s soft, beautiful, and hard to replicate. However, there are a few downsides.
The obvious one is ethical – a lot of people are uncomfortable wearing real fur, so if that’s you, skip this option. You’ll enjoy yourself a lot more if you don’t have guilt thrown into your play session.
Real fur is also a lot more expensive, and it’s harder to clean. If you’re not extremely careful, it can be easy to ruin it.
- Faux fur
Faux fur, fake fur, or synthetic fur is much more affordable and easier to clean than the real thing. Plus, you can rest easy knowing no animals were harmed for your sexual pleasure.
Fake fur also opens up a world of possibilities when it comes to different colors, textures, and qualities. You’d be hard-pressed to find a real unicorn tail on the market.
Unfortunately, it has some downsides too. Some people don’t like the plasticky feeling of fake fur. Luckily though, faux fur is getting much better and harder to distinguish from real fur.
How do you clean it?
Faux fur can be cleaned carefully with a mild soap detergent and a cool blow-dry. Don’t ever leave it damp, as this will cause unwanted odors and potentially damage your tail.
Real fur takes a little more attention when cleaning. It’s best kept in a cold area and with good air circulation so that the leather doesn’t dry out.
Ideally, you’ll clean it with professional fur products, but mild soap and lukewarm water can work.
Remember to brush it regularly, too!
When it comes to the butt plugs themselves, try to deal with them separately to the tails.
Antibacterial (but gentle) soap is necessary, with some warm water. Wipe them thoroughly after every use.
What are the pros and cons of a tail butt plug?
Honestly, there are so few cons to a tail butt plug that I had trouble thinking of any! The main concern is that cleaning them can be time-consuming. Other than that, it’s all good!
They offer great anal stimulation, are easy to use, and are generally affordable. There’s a huge variety of different styles and colors available, so you’re bound to find something you love. And the potential for fantasy, primal, and pet roleplay is a great way to bring some extra spice into the bedroom.
If you’ve ever been curious about any of those kinks, a tail butt plug is an easy choice!
Where can I buy the best tail butt plug online?
Both these stores are reliable and have great reputations. And if you’re anything like me, you’ll be happy to know they’re both ethical, queer-friendly, and feminist businesses. What’s not to love?
What to avoid when looking for anal plugs with Animal tails?
There are a few things to avoid when looking for pet play butt plugs.
- Inferior materials
The skin inside your anus is particularly sensitive, so you want to be extra careful when choosing the material of your anal plug. As a rule, silicone, glass, and metal (or stainless steel) are all safe choices.
If you see anything made of porous materials, though, run in the opposite direction. These will harbor bacteria and can lead to infection.
- Weak vibrations
If you decide to go for vibrating butt plugs, it’s probably because you want to feel some extra sensations. Don’t be disappointed by buying a toy with a sub-par motor.
Check out user reviews to make sure the toy you’re buying has a motor powerful enough to give you the sensations you want.
- Poor construction
If you’re going to be sticking something in your holiest of holies, you want to make sure it’s well-made. The last thing you want is a trip to the ER because your butt plug snapped in the middle of rough sex.
Make sure you’re always buying from reputable brands to avoid such a calamity.
- Weird designs
There are a couple of tried and true designs when it comes to tail butt plugs. While it might be tempting to stray into uncharted territory, it’s better to play it safe and stick with the classic cone shape. This is especially true if you’re new to these anal toys.
So, hopefully, we’ve demystified the big wide world of animal tail plugs!
While you might find your standard tail plugs a bit boring, these animal tail butt plugs are sure to spice things up during your furry foreplay.
Whose idea was it to take a simple, assuming tail butt plug and stick a furry tail on the end of it?
We don’t know, but we want to thank them from the bottom of our deviant little hearts.