9 Best Fisting Dildos: Find The RIGHT Fist Sex Toy For You [2024]

Need help on your hunt to find the best fisting dildo? Let us present you with the 9 best fist sex toys your money can buy.

Fisting – an urban legend only achievable for professionals, right? Haha, not anymore! 

Wait! What? That’s right. There’s a secret to fisting that most people don’t know. And it’s a game-changer for anyone trying to experiment with hand sex, also known as fisting. 

So, what’s the secret? Well, that would be training your orifice to stretch.

It takes time, patience, and trust between partners. And toys, like our recommendations for the ten best fisting dildos. Let’s get kinky!

---

Top Fisting Dildos On The Market Today

---

If you want to be touched by a porn star’s hand, try the sexy and realistic Magic Hand by Doc Johnson, modeled after adult actress Belladonna from tapered duckbill fingers to creased knuckles and fingernails. 

Your muscles will need stretching to accommodate this toy, especially at the broadest and most challenging part – the knuckles.

Don’t be surprised if it takes you a few rounds to be able to thrust it fully.

The flat base does make this dildo tricky to use for anal play. But when used carefully, you’re sure to love the intense and snug pressure to your sphincter and prostate. 

The material is PVC though – which means you can’t fully sanitize the toy. Make sure to clean and dry it thoroughly.

---

Doc Johnson does it again with another mold of Belladonna’s hand called the Bitch Fist. Advanced users can enjoy being fist fucked by the realistic shape and size of a closed fist. 

It is a disappointment that this toy is PVC Sil-a-Gel.

Still, I do appreciate the attention to details like realistic veins, fingernails, creases, and even a thumb placed slightly higher than the rest of the fingers to provide a slight taper.

This clenched fist brings intense sensations. Use tons of lube, and once entered, twist the hand for maximum pressure on your inner walls or prostate. 

Again due to its base, make sure to hold it well when inserting anally.

---

The All Black is a 15″ long fist that has an incredibly realistic design, with fingernails, knuckles, and wrinkles.

This toy is quite flexible, which can make insertion difficult, but once it is in, it bends nicely with the body. 

I appreciate the tapered design of the outstretched fingers. There’s time to adjust to the gradual size increase before reaching the widest point – the knuckles.

All the realism means the toy will need careful cleaning after each use.

---

If a plug is more your thing, the All Black Fist Butt Plug could be your go-to for fist fucking or stretching.

Put it in and wear it all day for extra stretching and the constant feeling of fullness. 

This plug provides a slight taper design from the closed fist with different length realistic knuckles that can bring a popping sensation as you ease them in. 

There are three sizes, all with a large flared base for both anal or vaginal play. The narrowed neck provides stability for hands-free or couple’s play.

Though, it is made from vinyl rubber, that may contain phthalates (potentially toxic to the body).

For a non-realistic silicone option, check out the Tantus H-Bomb. It has a first-like shape, 9” of usable length and 3.7” of diameter at the widest point.

---

The Tantus Fist Trainer XL is the nonrealistic fisting dildo for experienced users, with an impressive size of 10″ insertable length and 2.6″ diameter (~8.2” around).

Once past the tapered bulbous head, this fisting toy narrows in size, reducing some of the stretchings you just did.

But the pleasure you get from the ribbed neck is all the apology you’ll need. 

The flared base makes this fisting dildo perfect for anal or harness play. The only downside – it’s not suction cup compatible.

---

If you are searching for a toy to get you ready for a real fisting the Inner Band Trainer by Tantus will be there for you. Lather on some lube and get ready to stretch. 

While not shaped like a fist, the pointed tip of this tapered cone is perfect for easy insertion.

And you have time to adjust to the slight stretch before you reach the full intensity of this dildo.

Even for the depth novices, the girth (2” in diameter, or ~6.3” around) will be accessible, as The Band Trainer is super soft and flexible. 

The flared base makes it perfect for anal play, and you can even use it with compatible harnesses for hands-free play, though there is not suction cup option. 

---

If you’re an advanced player, or search for versatility try the Rebel Intruder. It is a 22” long toy with a hand on each side. 

This is a 2-in-1 toy, really. 

The open fist side has a tapered shape that will be easier to insert and play with first. It measures 8” around its widest point.

Once fully ready, proceed to a closed fist, that goes up to 9” in its widest point. 

For especially kinky ones, the flexible nature and dual hands bring a double penetration option to the table. 

But use care when cleaning as the realistic knuckle creases and fingernails can collect bacteria. 

---

And A Few Extras

Since you are here for fisting fun, these two products might come handy!

This hollow silicone plug serves well for a warm up for fisting. It can also make a great sleeve for your partner or your favorite toy and bring a completely new sensation to the play.

Fold the plug when inserting, and it will open up inside thus getting you ready for upcoming fullness. 

While thrusting, a small rolled lip can stimulate the prostate. And if left inside, the flared base will prevent the plug from slipping in. 

There are 4 sizes to choose from. The smallest option has 4” of usable length and 6.75” around the widest point, while XXL is 5” long and 10.25” around.

---

Once you’re ready to jump into the fun of fisting with a real hand, break out an 18.5″ latex glove.

No more worrying about messy interactions, getting scratched by nails, or irritation from calluses. 

Sprinkle talcum powder on your hand to make the glove slip on better but be ready to put in some work to get the hand inside. 

Once on, wait five to ten minutes for the latex to warm up enough to fit comfortably. Lather on some water-based lube and get to fist fucking. 

The glove might be too tight for some people though.

Also, it is a good idea to check in with your partner before purchase, since some might be allergic to latex.

---

What to Watch Out for When Shopping For Fisting Dildos?

Materials

The most crucial factor you should consider before purchasing a sex toy is the type of material.

Silicone is best because it’s body-safe, durable, comfortable, and easy to clean. But it’s often more expensive.

Another common material is PVC – polyvinyl chloride. PVC is a porous material and can contain carcinogens and phthalates, which can cause reproductive problems. 

If you plan to use a PVC sex toy, consider covering your toy with a condom to protect your body and always clean and dry the toy very thorougly.

---

Size increments

The biggest challenge with fisting dildos is their large size. When shopping for your fisting dildo, consider your current capabilities or maybe practice with the best anal stretching toys.

Measure the biggest toy you can take in and move up in 0.25″ increments (in diameter), so you don’t hurt yourself while stretching.

---

Length

Most fisting dildos are pretty long. You may find that it takes some time to work up to insert the entire toy in your orifice. 

With fisting, you receive penetration by the whole hand and sometimes up past the wrist. If you want a dildo with more length, consider getting one with outstretched fingers tucked into a duckbill. 

---

Tapered tip

Most fisters prefer using toys that have a tapered tip. Tapered shapes allow for easier insertion and help with stretching as the toy widens the further down you go.

Tapered tips are a Godsend when you’re trying to train your vagina or ass to stretch for fisting. Your body has time to accustom to the size as you’re sliding in before the toy starts to widen.

---

Where To Shop For a Fisting Dildo?

When shopping for sex toys, use a reputable sex toy website instead of Amazon or eBay, as you might get a knockoff version there. 

Using a dedicated sex toy shop provides shopping safety and privacy, as well as a variety of toy options. A few of our favorite sex toy companies are:

• UberKinky
• Lovehoney
• Tantus
• Mr. Hankey

You can read more on this topic in our guide on where to buy sex toys online.

---

Anal vs. Vaginal Fisting – What You Should Know?

One of the biggest concerns people have about fisting is that once you stretch your vagina or anus, there is no going back. However, this is far from the truth. 

The vagina stretches naturally for childbirth, so training for fisting isn’t as difficult as you would expect. It does require time, patience, and preparation. But once done, your hole goes back to normal. 

The anus can be more challenging to stretch as there are two muscles, called sphincters, that you have to pass.

Stretching your anal cavity to accommodate fisting requires a great deal of training with different sized toys (look for toys intended for anal stretching). Plus, lots of lube! 

Start small and work your way up. As with vaginas, the anus will return to normal after playtime.

---

Exercises to Warm up before fisting

• Start with foreplay 
• Stretch with fingers first
• When ready, move onto a smaller size starter toy (check out other dildos in this guide for more options.)
• Switch to larger toys when feeling of fullness stops
• Use lots of lube
• Take your time (it can take 20 minutes to an hour warming up).

---

Conclusion

Fisting is no longer a taboo activity only seen in hardcore porn.

With proper preparation, anyone can fist.

Fisting requires patience, dedication, stretching, and absolute trust between partners. And hopefully one of the ten best fisting dildo we discussed today.