17 Best Anal Fleshlights (Most Realistic & Tightest) That Feel Like A Real Butt [2021]

Discover the best anal Fleshlight available today! We tested the most realistic & tightest toys in the market to help you find the best one for you.

best anal fleshlight

Are you looking for an anal Fleshlight because: 

  1. You want a replica of your favorite pornstar’s ass? 
  2. You love the tighter orifice and feeling of anal? 
  3. You want the fun of butt sex without the hassle that comes with it? 
  4. All of the above? 

If you answered any of those, then you’re in the right place. 

Choosing the best butt sleeve can be a tough choice, so I’ve done the hard work for you. 

I love butt stuff, so I’ve spent a while in and around anal Fleshlights. I could have read the complete works of Shakespeare in that time, or learned to play the flute… 

…But instead, I “researched” Fleshlights until I came up with my list of the 17 Best Anal Sleeves. 

You’re welcome. 

And if you want the best of the butts, here’s the Top 3.

SexualAlpha Top Pick

My Top Pick goes to Riley Reid Euphoria. It has a unique cross-hatched design that offers a kind of stimulation that you won’t find anywhere else. It doesn’t feel like real anal – the pure sensation is better. 

Tightest Anal Fleshlight

Elsa Jean Treat sure lives up to its name. What a treat! It’s the tightest-feeling anal Fleshlight I’ve tried, with strong textures and alternating chambers that really amp up the pressure and intensity of feeling. There’s no chance you’ll ever get bored with this. 

Most Realistic Anal Fleshlight

And for realism, it’s hard to look past Lana Rhoades Karma. The ripples and soft ribs feel like an exaggerated version of the real anal experience, so you can live out your fantasies and easily imagine it’s more than just a plastic sleeve. 

Don’t forget that Fleshlight has a Loyalty program that lets you earn points in a few different ways. You can later use those points as money off your purchase.


Top 3 Anal Fleshlights In 2021

Elsa Jean Treat

Elsa Jean Treat

4.7/5

Insertable Length: 9”
Diameter: 0.4”- 1.5”

Riley Reid Euphoria

Riley Reid Euphoria

4.8/5

Insertable Length: 9” 
Diameter: 0.5” – 1.2”

Lana Rhoades Karma

4.6/5

Insertable Length: 9” 
Diameter: 0.8”-1.8”


Top Anal Fleshlights in 2021

1. Riley Reid Euphoria

SexualAlpha Top Pick

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.5”1.2”

PROS

  • Intricate, unique texture
  • Very intense 
  • Great choice for most sizes

CONS

  • Can over-stimulate during climax
  • Doesn’t feel realistic

Riley Reid and her Euphoria sleeve are the definition of “0-100 really f***ing quick”.

You push through that tight, welcoming butt hole, and you’re greeted by a unique square grid pattern with intersecting lines and pyramids. It’s like a 3D plaid pattern inside. So I could say I look good in a plaid shirt and feel good in a plaid butthole! 

It doesn’t feel like a butt, but DAMN, it is stimulating.

There’s no second to rest and recover your senses as you thrust through the square lines and bumps. It’s intense, to say the least. 

Euphoria has three chambers of varying tightness, from “tight” to “very tight”. They all give a nice squeeze and a sense of weight, which adds a lot to the whole experience. 

I gotta say though the stimulation can be a lot. 

If you get really sensitive when you finish, it might be too much for you. 

But hey – “this Fleshlight feels too good” isn’t exactly a dealbreaker for most dudes, now is it? 


2. Elsa Jean Treat

Tightest Anal Fleshlight

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.4” – 1.5” 

PROS

  • Tight, gripping experience
  • Lots of variation
  • Good for longer and shorter penises

CONS

  • Hard to clean and dry

Treat has three chambers where each is different from the last. The first one is filled with some big soft bumps that caress and massage. Then it gets tighter and twistier, giving you some incredible head stimulation. 

There are two areas of tight, pressing rings that you have to push through to get past. That resistance feels amazing and gives you some sense of realism even with the intense texture all around you. 

The second set of rings is a bit too far in for most guys to enjoy, which is a shame. 

If you’ve got about 6” or more to work with, then you’re going to experience it all. But even if you’re not hung, Treat’s massaging texture and lovely pressure are well worth the price.

Treat isn’t the all-out narrowest sleeve you can buy, but it gives the feeling of flesh gripping you tightly and pressing against you better than any other anal Fleshlight. 

It starts out gentler and wider, then tightens up towards the middle to entice you to go deeper and deeper until you can’t take it anymore. 

Most very tight Fleshlights are repetitious and can get boring, but Elsa Jean’s Treat both squeezes and keeps things interesting from the first inch to the last


3. Lana Rhoades Karma

Most Realistic Anal Fleshlight

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.8” – 1.8” (throughout the sleeve)

PROS

  • Realistic butthole feeling
  • Penetration is intense
  • Nice pulling suction

CONS

  • Repetitive texture
  • Ribs are hard to clean out properly

Karma pulls you in like she wants you inside of her with a sort of tugging sensation. 

On top of that, the entrance is tight and requires some effort to get inside properly, which adds a lot to the realistic effect. 

It has real resistance and weight, and the soft ribs right behind the entrance can trick you into believing you’re banging a real butt for a minute. 

Once you’re inside, you get a lot of ribs and bumps that gradually get tighter as you go further in. If you have what I like to call ADHDick, where you get bored easily, then Karma might be too repetitive. 

But for me, the rippling sensation and pulsing rings make Lana Rhoades’s Karma the perfect mix of lifelike feeling and intense stimulation

PRO TIP: Have the end cap screwed about halfway to maximize the pulling feeling and increase the realism even further.

Also, make sure you CLEAN OUT those ribbed sections carefully. Admittedly, it’s kind of a hassle to keep her clean, but when has good anal ever been effortless? 


4. Adriana Chechik Next Level

Best For Large Penises

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.2” – 1.8” 

PROS

  • Most variety, never a dull moment
  • Fairly easy to clean 
  • Tight and stimulating

CONS

  • You should be 6” or more to get the most out of this sleeve

Adriana Chechik is renowned for her anal and DP scenes, so it makes sense that her butt sleeve goes HARD. 

Just like her scenes, there’s never a dull moment with Next Level. 

Nubs, bumps, twists, ribs, constrictions… this sleeve’s got it all. If you move forward slowly, then every millimeter is a new surprise

It’s pretty tight the whole way along, so you feel the whole texture vividly even if you speed things up. 

But the reason this is the best anal Fleshlight for larger penises is that toothed spiraling section. It feels like being sucked down a vortex full of tongues. 

And if that sounds creepy, well, you just have to try it. It’s so good that honestly more Fleshlights should have this as part of their designs.


5. Eva Lovia Spice

Best For Easy Cleaning

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.4” – 1.18” 

PROS

  • Clean and dry in hours, not days
  • Very tight
  • Pro 3

CONS

  • Not very interesting texture
  • Not good if you’re very thick

Elsa Jean Treat might be the best tight butt Fleshlight (in my humble opinion), but for the actual tightest, it’s probably Eva Lovia Spice. 

Despite being both ultra-tight AND ribbed, Spice is surprisingly easy to clean and dry. 

With a grippy orifice and a ribbed entrance that goes down to less than half an inch, your dick is going to feel some serious pressure. 

Most of the time, a tighter sleeve is going to be much harder to clean and take forever to dry, but with the Spice, there’s nothing to pick up or hold on to fluids, so it rinses out easily. 

And drying only takes a few hours. This might sound like a lot, but some other FL Girls (like Karma) can take a day or more. 

If you want a tight butt that’s lower maintenance than most, this is your best option. 


6. Brandi Love Shameless

Most Exciting Unique Texture

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.5” – 1.9” 

PROS

  • Not tight but very intense
  • Great choice for thicker penises

CONS

  • Takes a lot of lube
  • Difficult to clean

Kind of the opposite of Spice, Brandi Love Shameless is all about the intense patterns. 

It has three textures. First up, there’s a pretty narrow entrance that offers good resistance, leading on to some standard bumps.

So far, so normal. 

But then it opens out into a wider chamber lined with a grid of geometric patterns that alternates and crisscrosses to keep you guessing. 

Finally, for your head, once you bottom out, there are some big round bumps joined by more lines that massage you to completion. 

Each chamber feels completely different, and they all have their unique pleasure to offer: pressure, intricacy, and stimulation


7. Stoya Epic

Most Intense Anal Fleshlight

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.6” – 1.8” 

PROS

  • Different texture every inch
  • Tight opening
  • Good for going fast or slow

CONS

  • Best suited for longer penises
  • Textures might be too close together to feel them all

You might need a longer penis to get the most out of Epic since that’s where you’ll find some of the best textures. 

At first, there’s a small opening that starts off gentle enough with some light bumps and ridges. 

But then the further down Stoya’s hole you go, the WILDER it gets.

A tight canal halfway in leads to some big bumps and textured grooves that will satisfy even the most desensitized of dongs. 

The quick-changing variety means Epic is a great toy for thrusting fast in the beginning, then pushing deeper and experiencing the crazy ride in the second half. 

You’ll probably need some Gatorade and a lie-down. 


8. Pure Stamina

Best for Stamina Training

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.45” – 0.6” 

PROS

  • Good for edging and stamina training
  • Cheaper than FL Girls
  • Gold case (if you like that)

CONS

  • Same texture all the way through
  • Not very subtle

A narrow, dense forest of bumps with a super-tight butt orifice. 

That’s a lot to deal with. 

If you have trouble holding off your orgasm, it’s a great training device, while if you’re an expert, then it’s a wonderful butt hole for edging. 

There are no gaps, no space for you to rest in. It’s all intensity all the way. 

For a lot of guys, the constant texture can get boring, but for others, it’s a good thing. Sudden changes can be overstimulating and give you that electric shock feeling, especially when you’re close to finishing. 

So having a highly stimulating but predictable sleeve can be just the thing for those guys! 

Sure there are newer and more intricate sleeves now that are even more intense, but few build you up to orgasm quite like the STU. 


9. Go Jolt

Best For Travel

Insertable Length: 6.5” | Diameter: – 

PROS

  • Compact and easier to hide than most Fleshlights
  • Ergonomic design

CONS

  • Lube-hungry

The Go Jolt Butt has a ribbed texture that doesn’t change much, so it’s good for guys who get overstimulated. 

That doesn’t mean you can’t feel anything. The ribs give some intriguing rubbing sensation on the corona and head

At just 7 inches in total, the Go Jolt Butt is a great choice for anal lovers who travel a lot or worry about being able to hide a full-size Fleshlight. It’s cheaper than FL Girls, too! 


10. Dillion Harper Crave

Best For Suction

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: wider than most

PROS

  • Amazing suction
  • Good for wider schlongs
  • Cleanup is easy

CONS

  • Wide middle chamber is not great for narrow dudes

Crave is a good description. First, because it sucks you in like she craves having you in her butt, and second because you’ll crave more once you’ve tried it. 

It has a tight entry point that widens out into a fairly broad canal with triangle shapes and sharp bumps. 

It’s more realistic than it sounds – exaggerated folds and bumps rather than something you’d never imagine in a real butt. 

The width of the chambers means you feel more of the details of the texture as you thrust until you get to the middle chamber – the PARTY piece. 

Generally, butt Fleshlights have good suction, but Crave takes the cake. It sucks and slurps, almost like her butt is giving you a blowjob. 

Didn’t know you wanted that but now you do, am I right? 


11. Ana Foxxx Velvet

Best For Vibrating Sensation

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.5” – 0.8” 

PROS

  • Creates a vibrating sensation
  • Detailed pattern good for going fast or slow

CONS

  • Texture is repetitive

If you want a low-intensity sleeve with a twist, check this out. 

Velvet is a one-chamber canal lined with low-key detailed bumps and nubs that combine to give you a subtle vibrating sensation

It’s not like a real vibrating sleeve. It’s more like – have you ever been with someone who shakes and shivers really fast when they climax? 

Yeah, it feels like that. Except all the time. Pretty awesome, right? 

And if you go slow, you get a lovely detailed anal adventure that’s good for edging. 

Since it’s just one continuous canal, Velvet is also decent for cleaning and drying. 


12. Alexis Texas Tornado

Best Milking Sensation

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.5” – 1.5”

PROS

  • Realistic 
  • Twists and spirals reactively
  • Doesn’t need much lube

CONS

  • Not very tight

If you like gentle milking sensations rather than high-impact bumps, this is the sleeve for you. 

Tornado has twisting strips with soft holes inside for that extra bit of gentle stimulation to give you that trance-like feeling of being milked

It spirals and swirls around you, making it feel more interactive than most other Fleshlights. 

It almost feels like if you let go, it will keep moving on its own. 

And because it slides and spins so easily, you don’t need much lube to have a good time.


13. Milan Christopher King

Best Male Anal Fleshlight

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.2” – 1.8” 

PROS

  • Several intense chambers
  • Great head stimulation

CONS

  • Could be tighter

King has ribbed ridges leading up to a round chamber of “spikes” that stimulate from all directions at once. 

It offers a blend of smoothness and friction, with low-intensity ribs leading to stronger-feeling chambers with more pronounced textures. 

It balances out to medium-intensity overall, starting out pretty tame and getting crazier the deeper you go in. 

That means unless you’re as hung as Milan Christopher apparently is (if his dildo is anything to go by) you might miss out on the wilder end of the sleeve

Or you can just take the sleeve out of the case and go full manual mode to get the textures you want where you want them. He won’t mind! 


14. Levi Karter Explosive

Tightest Male Anal Fleshlight

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.4” – 0.8” 

PROS

  • High suction
  • Tight

CONS

  • Hard to clean and dry

“Explosive” is a bold name to give to a butt sleeve, but Levi Karter lives up to the hype. 

When you first penetrate it you get some pushback that makes the whole experience feel more realistic. I wish all butt sleeves did the same, honestly. 

Once you’re inside, you’re greeted by narrow chambers lined with bold, striking ridges and distinctive studs

The tightness is helped a lot by the powerful suction, which draws you in deeper and deeper. 

If you’re looking for a tight man’s butt to enjoy, look no further. 


15. Asa Akira Asahole

Best Texture Variety

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.5” – 1.3” 

PROS

  • Huge texture variety
  • High and low intensity in one sleeve

CONS

  • Doesn’t dry well

100% the best name of any Fleshlight. Get it? Asahole? Like ass… you get it. Classic.

There’s a lot going on inside Asahole. A spiraling chamber of soft squared lumps that fondle the glans leads into a tighter ring of dense bumps. That’s an intense first half. 

Then in the second half it smooths out significantly for a very different but equally enjoyable relaxing ride. 

That VARIETY means you can go hard and fast for high-intensity fun, or get in deeper and take it slow so you can enjoy the Fleshlight equivalent of a spa day.


16. Lisa Ann Savage

Stimulating Ribbed Textures

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: wider than most

PROS

  • Can rotate for more different feelings
  • Realistic
  • Great for edging

CONS

  • If you don’t like ribs it doesn’t offer much 

The best thing about Savage is that you can ROTATE it for a different feeling. The sleeve texture is split into two sides, let’s call them top and bottom. 

On the top you have a smooth, snaking line that’s incredibly soft and pillowy. It slides along giving horizontal stimulation instead of the usual vertical. 

And on the bottom side there are prominent ribs running the entire length of the sleeve. This side is much more stimulating. 

You can revolve it around for more or less intensity without changing your depth or speed. 

That means Savage is ideal for edging since you can ease off with just a slight movement. 


17. Riley Steele Lit

Intricate Sleeve Design

Insertable Length: 9” | Diameter: 0.6” – 1.8”

PROS

  • Very tight entry
  • Detailed and intricate patterns
  • Good suction

CONS

  • Looser than average

Riley Steele’s Lit seems like it’s been overlooked for a while. Maybe because the name isn’t very memorable, or it looks too similar to other textures, I don’t know. 

But it’s highly underrated. 

Lit is filled with firm bumps and patterns that leave a big impression from the first time you try it. 

It’s got good suction that keeps the patterns clinging to your shaft, so there’s a lot of FRICTION going on. 

And it has one of the tightest entries of any Fleshlight Girl sleeve.

Definitely not a sleeve to be ignored. 


Buying Guide: How To Choose The Best Anal Fleshlight

There are a few things you should keep in mind when it comes to choosing an anal Fleshlight. 

Here are the most important things to consider. 

How Tight Do You Like It? 

Tightness is good for a few reasons. 

First, it’s great for smaller guys to feel more of the texture and enjoy themselves. 

Most guys love the feeling of pressure squeezing on their shafts, which is more intense if the sleeve is tighter. 

But there’s a balance to it. If you’re girthier and/or the sleeve is super tight, then the texture is too squished to feel like much of anything. 

And there’s the possibility of overstimulating. If things get too much then it can be counterproductive and make you lose your groove. 

So much so that your peen might not like that sleeve ever again. So it’s a serious consideration! 

And what about the entrance?

With anal Fleshlights a tight entrance looks and feels more realistic. Buttholes are tighter than vaginas. Duh, right? So obviously the Fleshlights should follow the same logic. 

A particularly tight orifice creates a kind of seal when combined with suction so that it grips and holds you inside. Good times.

Realism vs Intensity

If you paid attention in high school Physics, you’ll remember the famous Third Law Of Fleshlight Dynamics: 

The More Realistic A Fleshlight Is, The Less Intense It Tends To Be. 

This is for the simple reason that real butts aren’t very intricate. 

They don’t have complex patterns or internal bumps and edges to stimulate your shaft. 

If a butt does have those things, it’s probably a medical issue. Anyway. 

If you want something super-realistic, then don’t expect it to be incredibly intense. 

There are a few Fleshlights that balance realism and intensity very well, like Karma and Velvet, but those are exceptions. 

So pick your poison. Or get a mix of each. 

Discretion

So, good news first: Fleshlights are pretty quiet to use. 

They make a bit of noise, mainly slurping or the occasional sound of air escaping, but otherwise there’s no moving parts except for you. That means not too much noise. 

Now for the bad news: they’re pretty big and hard to hide. 

So to keep things nice and discreet you’ll want to keep your Fleshlights somewhere that other people won’t look (if that’s a risk). 

BUT(T) you also need to keep them in a cool dry place that’s reasonably well ventilated. Otherwise they’ll get sticky, dusty, or even moldy. And no-one wants that. 

Make sure you have a place picked out before you start collecting asses.


Conclusion

Hopefully by now you have a better idea of what makes an anal Fleshlight good. 

And you should also know which butt is next on your list. 

So remember to stock up on lube, keep them clean and dry and have fun!

Dainis Graveris

Dainis Graveris

Over last 4 years Dainis have helped millions of people through his advice on this site (200+ guides and 1M+ visits/monthly). His work & advice has appeared on sites like: Healthline, Vice, Cosmopolitan, Men's Health, WomensHealthMag, MindBodyGreen & more. Read More

Got Questions? Ping me on Twitter.